Showing posts with label 9/11. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 9/11. Show all posts

Sunday, November 7, 2010

9/11 Workers face Deadline for Health Settlement

Associated Press

 
Thousands of laborers, police officers and firefighters suing New York City over their exposure to toxic World Trade Center dust have until Monday to decide whether to join a legal settlement that could ultimately pay them as much as $815 million.

More than 10,000 people have sued the city and a long list of companies that handled the massive cleanup of lower Manhattan after the 9/11 attacks.

Many claim to be suffering from illnesses caused by inhaling the pulverized remnants of the twin towers. Their lawsuits blame the government and its contractors for failing to provide proper equipment to protect their lungs.

The vast bulk of the litigation could be over on Monday.

Paul Napoli, a leader of the legal team representing most of the plaintiffs, told The Associated Press on Friday that with Monday's deadline looming on the largest and most important of several related settlements, 90 percent of those eligible had said "yes" to the deal.

An all-out effort was being made to get the rest to join on, he said. He said he and other lawyers in the firm were being besieged with questions from clients still trying to chose between taking the money, or rejecting it and taking their case to trial.

"A lot of people appear to be making a last minute decision," he said. "It's like tax day ... there is going to be a lot of last minute wrangling."

Under the terms of the deal, at least 95 percent of the plaintiffs must opt to participate for the settlement to become effective. Napoli said he was feeling good about hitting the target, although he added that getting the paperwork finished for each claim by midnight on the deadline will be no small feat.

"I'm hopeful there will be a little leeway," he said.

The Monday deadline technically applies only to a settlement negotiated between Napoli's legal team and the city's attorneys in the spring. That deal would distribute as much as $712 million among the workers, based on the severity of their illnesses and the likelihood they could be linked to the 9/11 attacks.

But since that deal was inked, the firm has worked out similar agreements with other defendants in the case, including the agency that owns the World Trade Center site, that will add to the total value of the pot.

An insurance company that represented the operators of barges that carried rubble from Manhattan to Staten Island after the attacks has agreed to settle for $28 million, Napoli said. Other entities, including those involved in the debris-sorting operation at the city's Fresh Kills landfill, have agreed in principle on settlements that will add another $100 million, he said.

Some rescue and recovery workers who had been outspoken critics of the deal early on have decided in the end to sign.

Retired Fire Department Lt. Kenny Specht, who now leads a fraternal group for New York firefighters, was among them.

Like others, he said the payments responders will receive under the deal will never be enough to compensate for their illnesses. But he called the settlement, "the best we were going to do."

Fighting for more money in court, he said, seemed like it could wind up a losing battle, in part because "the shelf life" of sympathy for 9/11 responders is running out.

"I felt in my bones that it was expiring," he said.

He added that he was also concerned about the difficulty of trying to prove that common illnesses like cancer were caused by trade center dust. So far, scientists studying the issue has yet to find any such link.

"We are nine years outside of Sept. 11, and we live in a very technologically advanced time," he said. "If nine years after the fact, they have still not attributed the cancers that are killing us to 9/11, either they have that information, and there is no way they are going to publish it, or there just isn't a correlation."

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

NYC, 9/11 Workers Reach $712.5 Million Injury-Claims Settlement

Bloomberg Business Week

 
Lawyers for 10,000 workers claiming illnesses from rescue, recovery and debris removal after the Sept. 11 World Trade Center attack have agreed with New York City on a $712.5 million compensation fund to settle the cases.

The city and its WTC Captive Insurance Co., set up with $1 billion from the federal government, joined with plaintiffs’ attorneys to present the agreement today to U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein in Manhattan.

The accord offers more money than an earlier proposal, and creates eligibility criteria for compensation to those suffering from diseases and injuries including asthma and terminal cancer, said Margaret Warner, Captive Insurance’s lawyer. The agreement also caps attorney’s fees at 25 percent of awards. Each claimant will get a free cancer-insurance policy with a $100,000 benefit.

“This is a settlement that is fair, provides compensation now, certainty now, and closure for these plaintiffs who have waited so long,” Warner said as she presented its terms to Hellerstein.

Describing the agreement as “a very good deal,” the judge signed an order dismissing the lawsuit, and set a June 23 public hearing for claimants and their attorneys to raise any objections. At least 95 percent of the plaintiffs must consent to the agreement for it to become legally binding.

The settlement, if approved, means each plaintiff will be “assured of a fair deal that puts money in their hand fast,” Hellerstein said.

More Money

In March, the judge rejected a previous agreement that would have paid at least $575 million and a maximum of $657 million to claimants. He told the parties to return to the negotiating table to produce a settlement with more money for the plaintiffs.

While lawyers for both sides appealed that decision, disputing the judge’s power to reject the agreement, they agreed to continue negotiations. Today, each side characterized the new accord as a better deal.

The agreement cuts more than $50 million from potential attorney’s fees by reducing the cap to 25 percent from 33 percent in the earlier proposal.

Those claiming debilitating respiratory diseases, such as nonsmokers who contracted severe asthma within seven months of exposure to the smoke and airborne debris from the attack, may get $800,000 to $1.05 million, Captive Insurance said in a news release. Death benefits could reach as much as $1.5 million.

Award Amounts

Plaintiffs with no qualifying injury who claim fear of becoming sick will receive $3,250. All qualifying claimants will get special insurance policies through MetLife Inc. providing a benefit of up to $100,000 in the event they are diagnosed with certain blood and respiratory cancers while covered, Captive Insurance said.

Kenneth Feinberg, an attorney who acted as special master of the federal September 11th Victim Compensation Fund awarding money to surviving families of the attack, volunteered to hear appeals of the claims awards at no cost to the fund.

“This is a fair settlement of a difficult and complex case that will allow first responders and workers to feel fairly compensated for injuries suffered following their work at Ground Zero,” Mayor Michael Bloomberg said.

Captive Insurance was funded by the Federal Emergency Management Agency to insure the city and debris-removal contractors. The city couldn’t get adequate liability coverage in the commercial market to deal with the rescue, recovery and clean-up work at the trade-center site in lower Manhattan.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

The 9/11 Lawyers Deserve Praise: Don't Arbitrarily Slash their Fees

NY Daily News


In light of Judge Alvin Hellerstein's stunning Friday ruling rejecting the legal settlement of 10,000 workers injured in the post-9/11 search, rescue and cleanup efforts, it is time to reassess the agreement - including the legal fees paid to the plaintiffs' attorneys.

The judge said he feared that too much of the deal would be consumed by legal fees - and worried that Ground Zero responders might be pressured into signing on before understanding just how much money they were due to receive.

Fair enough. But one thing that should not happen is for the plaintiffs' lawyers to have their fees arbitrarily slashed. Instead, it makes far more sense for the City of New York to pick up the heroes' legal bills.

Simply cutting the fees on the theory that the lawyers are being "too greedy" would be unfair and shortsighted in the extreme.
Lost in the impassioned rhetoric against the settlement - much of it directed at the plaintiffs' lawyers - is the simple fact that they have stood with the heroes for the past six years. The same cannot be said for the city's government or its contractors. They opposed the workers, even though the federal government gave the city $1 billion to cover the workers' losses.

If there are good characters and bad characters in this drama, the workers' lawyers are wearing white hats.

True, the lawyers did not agree to represent the workers for free. Their retainer agreements entitle them to contingent fees equal to one-third of the recovery plus expenses, about $200 million. New York law expressly deems fees of this level "fair and reasonable," except in medical malpractice cases, where a lower cap applies.

The workers were smart to hire lawyers at the prevailing rate. To understand why, consider one fact: The city paid a high-priced D.C. law firm more than $200 million to defeat the workers' claims.

In the civil justice system, money counts. Rich litigants defeat poor litigants most of the time. The workers needed to offset the city's enormous spending advantage. A person armed with a pea-shooter has little chance against a tank.

The workers countered the city's gambit by offering their lawyers contingent fees. In fact, they beat the city at its own game. The city took its $200 million in attorneys' fees from the insurance fund the federal government created. The workers did the same thing. By promising lawyers a fraction of their recoveries, they used the insurance fund to prevent the other side from defeating them by outspending them.

Few people know much about the risks and costs contingent fee lawyers incur. Talking with the workers' attorneys, I learned that they spent more than $3.15 million on filing fees alone. That was literally the price of opening the door to the U.S. District Court. If they lost the case, they would never have gotten that money back.

All told, the attorneys spent about $30 million of their own money with no guarantee of repayment. Why so much? Because for six years the city and its co-defendants fought the workers tooth and nail. For example, I'm told that in the 12 cases scheduled for trial in May, the defendants filed more than 200 motions to dismiss. Scorched earth tactics make lawsuits expensive. They also force plaintiffs' attorneys to expend enormous amounts of time.

The workers' lawyers devoted hundreds of thousands of hours to their clients' cause without receiving a nickel in payment. The defense lawyers, by contrast, bore no such risks. Their expenses were reimbursed as incurred and they were paid by the hour for their time each month.

Congress could have spared the workers the costs they incurred by reopening the 9/11 victims' compensation fund. It did not. The city could have saved them money by renouncing litigation and creating an administrative review process. It did not.

Litigation was the only avenue left, and as everyone knows, litigation is expensive. In fact, compared with many victims, the workers were lucky. The tort system regularly sends deserving plaintiffs home with nothing.

Nothing prevents the city from using the insurance fund or other monies to defray the workers' legal fees. By doing so, the city would enable them to keep their recoveries and would spread their legal costs across everyone who benefited from their public service. That seems right to me.

If, however, the court were to cut the lawyers' fees, attorneys would be discouraged from taking the next big case on contingency. Claimants who cannot afford to pay lawyers by the hour would then find themselves without counsel. And in our civil justice system, a victim without an attorney is unlikely to beat an opponent who has lawyered up.

Silver holds the McDonald Endowed Chair in Civil Procedure at the University of Texas School of Law.