Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Woman Stuck with Lawsuits After Sending Adopted Boy Back

Story first appeared in USA Today.

An American woman who adopted a Russian boy and later sent him back to Moscow on a one-way flight has been ordered to pay a sum of $150,000 and an additional $1,000 per month in child support until he's an adult, according to a Binghamton Family Lawyer familiar with the case.

On Thursday a Bedford County, Tenn., judge said the woman must begin making the child support payments in June and continue to pay until the boy, who is now 9 years old, turns 18. The Circuit Court Judge said the $150,000 includes damages for breach of contract, legal fees and support for the boy.

She sent the boy back to Russia in April of 2010 with a letter saying the child was disturbed, violent and she didn't want him anymore. The case created an international uproar and prompted Russia to temporarily halt its adoption program with the U.S.

The World Association for Children and Parents, which helped her adopt the child, then filed a lawsuit seeking child support.

Despite efforts from her child protective services defense lawyer, claiming that the Russiun Supreme Court had annulled the adoption, the Judge determined the verdict.

The woman has since moved to Redding, Calif., and has failed to show up at any of the hearings, said an attorney for the adoption agency. She has hired a series of three Tennessee lawyers to represent her but the most recent one, he said, has been granted permission to leave the case. She did, however, hire a court reporter to attend the hearing.

She filed a lawsuit last month in the Shasta County, Calif., Superior Court against representatives of a Russian orphanage saying the Russian Federation Supreme Court annulled the adoption. The suit states that in doing so, it denied defendants the ability to recover a sum of money in the form of child support from plaintiff.

The woman wants the California court to recognize the Russian decision. Her California attorney did not return calls seeking comment. No home listing for her in California could be found.

Adoption advocates hailed the Tennessee court order as a measure of justice for the boy, and said the judge's decision would show there are consequences to abandoning adopted children. They have said she never told social workers that she was having problems with the boy.

An El Reno Family Lawyer says that it has certainly caused concern on the part of Russian officials that unless there are consequences when a parent abandons a child placed in their home, there's a need for safeguards to make sure this never occurs.

The judge said in his order that when she adopted the boy she signed a contract acknowledging that it was possible the child could have physical, emotional or behavior problems that were unreported and even unknown to the adoption agency.

According to a Hackensack Family Lawyer, $58,000 of the $150,000 will pay for the past two years' worth of support and medical fees for the boy in Russia.

Court documents say the boy was hospitalized for three weeks after he returned to Moscow, but they don't say what he was treated for. He was later moved to an orphanage and then sent to another institution.


For more Law News, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For more national and worldwide Business News, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For more local and state of Michigan Business News, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For more Health News, visit the Healthcare and Medical News blog.
For more Electronics News, visit the Electronics America blog.
For more Real Estate News, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For more Advertising News, visit the Advertising, Marketing and Media blog.
For more Environmental News, visit the Environmental Responsibility News blog.
For information on website optimization or for the latest SEO News, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Friday, February 3, 2012

Polo Club Founder Adopts Girlfriend to Save Assets in DUI Case

First appeared on ABC News
A wealthy Florida polo club founder has adopted his longtime adult girlfriend in what attorneys believe may be a legal maneuver to protect his financial assets--which he estimates as "several hundred million dollars"--as he faces a trial for a drunk driving incident that killed a 23-year-old. A Hackensack Personal Injury Lawyer has been watching the case.

John Goodman, 48, formally adopted Heather Laruso Hutchins, 42, in October 2011. The couple started dating in 2009. Goodman is the founder of the International Polo Club Palm Beach in Wellington, Fla.
West Palm Beach Judge Glenn Kelley wrote in a court order that the twists in the case "border on the surreal and take the Court into a legal twilight zone."

"The Defendant has effectively diverted a significant portion of the assets of the children's trust to a person with whom he is intimately involved at a time when his personal assets are largely at risk in this case," the judge wrote. An Oklahoma City Estate Planning Lawyer is curious.

Goodman is being sued by Lili and William Wilson for the wrongful death of their son Scott Patrick Wilson, who had come home from college for his sister's birthday, and died in a car crash on Feb. 12, 2010.

According to police, Goodman, who was driving a Bentley, ran a stop sign and slammed into Wilson's car. Goodman did not call police or an ambulance, and left the crash scene on foot, police said. It was determined that Goodman's blood alcohol level was more than twice the legal limit.

Man Adopts Girlfriend, 42, Before Civil Suit Over DUI Death

Goodman's civil trial is set for March 27 and his criminal trial for charges of DUI manslaughter, vehicular homicide and leaving the scene of a crash is on March 6. He faces up to 30 years in prison if convicted. A Rochester NY Personal Injury Lawyer wonders what will happen.

Neither of Goodman's two biological children have reached the age of 35, the pre-determined age at which they can control their trust funds. Since Hutchins is over the age of 35, her adoption entitles her immediately to a one-third beneficiary interest in the trust.

The court had previously ruled that the assets owned by Goodman's children could not be considered part of his net worth in the calculations for assessing punitive damages for the Wilson family, but the family thinks the adoption should change the ruling.

"Plaintiffs view the adoption of Ms. Hutchins as a 'game-changer' and as grounds to now include the assets of the children's trust, at least in some fashion, in the punitive damages calculation," Kelley wrote.

Attorneys representing the Wilsons believe that the move is Goodman's way of maintaining control of his money.  A Chicago Estate Planning Lawyer is curious if this will work.

"By way of this adoption John Goodman effectively owns or has direct control of one-third of the trust assets," Wilson family attorney Scott Smith told ABCNews.com in an email. "It cannot go unrecognized that he has adopted his 42-year-old adult girlfriend as opposed to a child in need."

Goodman established the trust for his children in 1991 with $1.5 million. Within seven years, that trust had grown to more than $100 million and is currently worth "several hundred million dollars," according to his attorney.

"Nothing in this arrangement with Ms. Hutchins is illegal," Goodman's attorney Daniel Bachi said in a statement. "Everything that has been done by Mr. Goodman was done with the intention to preserve and grow the assets of the Trust for his two minor children, even should he personally be unable to continue his historical role in achieving these goals."

Bachi maintains that the adoption will have "no effect on the civil proceedings" and that Goodman does not benefit from it.

"Mr. Goodman asserts that the adoption makes Ms. Hutchings a beneficiary and, until a probate court holds otherwise, this Court will assume this is true," Kelley wrote.

The judge wrote that a probate court with jurisdiction over the trust will determine whether the adoption is a "sham," as it relates to the children's trust. A Sioux Falls Estate Planning Lawyer is wondering about similar cases.

On Jan. 25, a Palm Beach County judge denied Goodman's request to move the trial to Miami due to the negative publicity and attention he has received in the Palm Beach area since the accident.

"March will be an exhausting and understandably difficult time for Mr. and Mrs. Wilson, but they are prepared to move forward in honor of their only son's memory," Smith wrote.