Original Story: madison.com
Pressure could be building against Wisconsin’s caps on damages in medical malpractice lawsuits.
Two Milwaukee County cases are challenging the state’s $750,000 cap on non-economic damages, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reported this month.
A Dane County case challenging a separate $250,000 cap on total damages against UW-Madison doctors is pending in the state Court of Appeals. A Milwaukee Medical Malpractice Lawyer has experience managing injury cases involving medical malpractice.
One of the Milwaukee cases involves Ascaris Mayo, a 53-year-old mother of four who had to have all of her limbs amputated in 2011 after a strep infection went undetected at Columbia St. Mary’s Hospital in Milwaukee, the Journal-Sentinel reported.
In July, a jury awarded Mayo and her husband $25.3 million. That included $15 million for pain and suffering and $1.5 million for his loss of companionship, non-economic damages limited by state law to $750,000.
Tyree Roberts, 23, was awarded $2.2 million in June after a jury said nurses failed to recognize symptoms of compartment syndrome, which caused him to undergo several surgeries and lose sensation in his left leg. A Milwaukee Personal Injury Lawyer is reviewing the details of this case.
That award includes $1.5 million for pain and suffering, limited to $750,000 under the state cap adopted in 2006 after the state Supreme Court threw out the previous cap of $350,000, which was adjusted for inflation.
In hearings this month about the validity of the cap in the Milwaukee County cases, judges called into question the state’s $1.15 billion Injured Patients and Families Compensation Fund, which has grown in recent years as the number of malpractice cases has declined.
The fund, supported by premiums from doctors, covers malpractice awards over $1 million.
The $1.15 billion is an “obscene amount,” the Journal-Sentinel quoted Circuit Court Judge David Hansher as saying.
Wisconsin Medical Society lobbyist Mark Grapentine defended the size of the fund, saying it has to be robust to handle potential outlays.
The Milwaukee County cases appear to be headed to the state Supreme Court, the Journal-Sentinel reported.
In the Dane County case, Terri Fiez of Verona won a $1.8 million jury award last year for her husband’s death after he was treated at UW Hospital. The jury found Dr. Jonathan Keevil, who works for UW-Madison, negligent.
The state limits total damages against UW doctors and other state employees to $250,000.
Circuit Court Judge John Markson upheld the cap, citing a state Supreme Court’s ruling maintaining a similar $50,000 cap against municipalities.
But, Markson wrote, “I believe the plaintiffs provide cogent arguments that deserve close examination by our Supreme Court, which is the only court that can modify or overrule the decisions that I believe are controlling.”
Markson said the Legislature set the state employee cap in 1979 at $250,000, equal to $72,000 today. An equivalent cap today would be $800,000, he said.
Guy DuBeau, an attorney for the Wisconsin Hospital Association and the Wisconsin Medical Society, wrote in a brief in the appeal that the Legislature “crafted these policies consistent with the well accepted principle that it, and not the courts, is better suited to weigh the policies involved.”
William Gleisner, an attorney with the Wisconsin Association for Justice, wrote that the $250,000 cap is “an insult to the citizens of Wisconsin because it encourages public employees to believe that there is no downside to their failure to adhere to those basic standards, regulations or guidelines.”
Showing posts with label Medical Malpractice Lawsuits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medical Malpractice Lawsuits. Show all posts
Thursday, October 2, 2014
Wednesday, July 18, 2012
New York Hospitals: Also Uninsured
Story first reported from nytimes.com
Every hospital makes mistakes. But some New York City hospitals may not have enough money to pay for them.
Several of the city’s most troubled hospitals are partially or
completely uninsured for malpractice, state records show, forgoing what
is considered a standard safeguard across the country.\
Some have saved money to cover their liabilities, but others have used
up their malpractice reserves, meaning that any future awards or
settlements could come at the expense of patients’ care, and one
hospital has closed its obstetric practice, in part out of fear of
lawsuits.
Executives of these hospitals, most of which are in poor neighborhoods,
say their dire financial circumstances and high premiums make it
impractical to pay millions of dollars a year for insurance.
But insurance experts say that though dropping coverage may make
economic sense in the short term, it is hardly in the best interest of
patients, and in the long term it may be costly to hospitals and their
bondholders, including some bonds backed by the state, should large
judgments force them into bankruptcy.
Hospitals in New York do not need malpractice insurance to function, and
they need not tell patients when going “naked” or “bare,” in industry
parlance.
Many states do not require malpractice insurance, and New York is not
the only city where hospitals go without coverage. Generally the
uninsured hospitals are in areas where juries award big judgments,
insurance executives say.
There is no central record of which hospitals have insurance. But in
2009, the state Health Department took a survey of so-called
self-insured hospitals. It found that three — Interfaith Medical Center,
Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center and Wyckoff Heights Medical Center,
all in Brooklyn — were completely self-insured.
Twelve other hospitals across the city were partially self-insured,
including St. Vincent’s Hospital in Manhattan, which went bankrupt and
closed in 2010; Lenox Hill in Manhattan; Jamaica Hospital Medical Center
in Queens; and New York Hospital Queens.
Some of the 12 had bought insurance to cover lower-dollar or “primary”
claims, but not “excess” judgments. The others had excess coverage but
not primary.
The Health Department has not done a follow-up survey, but hospitals
that responded to questions about their coverage said it had not
changed.
In interviews, some hospital executives said their physicians had
separate insurance which is subsidized or reimbursed by the hospital.
Interfaith, for one, gives its emergency-room physicians a letter
promising to assume liability, said Luis A. Hernandez, the hospital’s
chief executive.
Without insurance, many hospitals set aside money to pay for claims, but
a review by The New York Times of state records and hospital financial
records indicates that several of the hospitals have insufficient
reserves to cover their malpractice liabilities.
Two of the hospitals without insurance have no money set aside,
according to their financial documents and interviews with hospital
officials. In the case of the third, Kingsbrook, it is unclear from
financial statements if it has any money in reserve.
Dr. Linda Brady, the hospital’s chief executive, was overseas and was
unavailable for comment, said Enid Dillard, a hospital spokeswoman. But
Ms. Dillard, when asked if the hospital was paying malpractice claims
out of its day-to-day budget, said that it was a fair conclusion.
In 2009, Wyckoff Heights Medical Center, in Bushwick, had $50,000 in its
malpractice fund; in 2010, the amount put aside to cover claims had
dwindled to “0,” according to its financial statements. Yet the hospital
listed professional liabilities of $37 million. Ramon Rodriguez, the
chief executive, declined to comment.
A jury awarded a $31.6 million judgment against the hospital in 2006,
which was later reduced to $12.9 million and is being paid out in
installments through 2018. As a result of that case, Mr. Hernandez said,
the hospital closed its obstetric unit because it could not afford the
liability. The hospital was also not delivering enough babies to justify
the expense, he said.
Henry W. Fust of Fust Charles Chambers, a Syracuse firm that provides
accounting services to hospitals across New York State, said that for
hospitals to “go totally naked” was very unusual and “would draw into
question the viability of the entity.” It would also be difficult for
any patient to recover money from hospitals like Wyckoff and Interfaith,
which are already deeply in debt.
An absence of insurance is generally a sign of double trouble,
signifying that rates have gone up because of high claims. Many
commercial insurance companies pulled out of New York years ago because litigation was frequent and excessive said
Edward J. Amsler, vice president of Medical Liability Mutual Insurance
Company, which is owned by its policyholders. Financially stable
hospitals have responded by banding together in groups like Mr.
Amsler’s, setting premiums and reserves and sometimes sharing risks.
(Lenox Hill has primary liability coverage through this company, setting
aside reserves for larger claims.)
Some hospital executives say, however, it is better to be effectively uninsured, because lawyers follow the money.
Having malpractice insurance is like asking for a lawsuit to be filed, said a former hospital
administrator who did not want to be named to avoid upsetting potential
employers. Malpractice lawyers said that underinsured hospitals put them
in a tricky position.
Lawyers say they were often forced to take payment on installment,
or to try to pin more blame on physicians, who may have their own
insurance. Martin Seinfeld, a malpractice lawyer, said he had had three
cases this year involving Jamaica Hospital and New York Hospital Queens
in which hospital lawyers had held out the specter of bankruptcy if he
did not reduce his demands.
When a hospital is bankrupt, its creditors, including malpractice
plaintiffs, are often forced to accept less than they are owed through
litigation.
Camela Morrissey, a spokeswoman for New York Hospital Queens, declined
to comment on Mr. Seinfeld’s assertion or on the hospital’s financial
condition. Jamaica also declined to comment.
Mr. Hernandez, of Interfaith, said the hospital was not trying to duck
responsibility.
An
earlier version of this article said incorrectly that Kingsbrook Jewish
Medical Center’s chief executive, Dr. Linda Brady, declined to comment.
She was in fact overseas and unavailable for comment, according to a
hospital spokeswoman.
For more national and worldwide Business News, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For more local and state of Michigan Business News, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For more Health News, visit the Healthcare and Medical News blog.
For more Electronics News, visit the Electronics America blog.
For more Real Estate News, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For more Law News, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For more Advertising News, visit the Advertising, Marketing and Media blog.
For more Environmental News, visit the Environmental Responsibility News blog.
For information on website optimization or for the latest SEO News, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Massachusetts Spearheads Medical Malpractice Reform Program
Story first appeared in The Boston Globe.
Seven Massachusetts hospitals plan to offer patients harmed by medical errors a prompt apology and financial settlements before they resort to lawsuits, part of a major new initiative to improve the state’s cumbersome medical malpractice system.
A coalition of physician, hospital, and patient groups planned to release details Wednesday of the initiative, called “Road Map to Reform,’’ which they predict will increase reporting of medical mistakes and cut down on lengthy litigation that drives up health care costs and fuels distrust between caregivers and patients.
The plan calls on doctors and nurses to fully disclose mistakes to patients and apologize. Three large insurers and a medical group have donated about $1 million to underwrite the initial work at the seven test hospitals, and the coalition hopes to implement the improvements statewide over the next several years. This is a fundamental transformation of the system. The whole system has created secrecy and denial.
While many people believe doctors are ethically obligated to acknowledge mistakes, they are often hesitant to do so because they fear lawsuits. At the same time, doctors practice “defensive medicine’’ by giving unneeded tests so that in the event of legal action, they can show they did everything possible. When cases do end up in court, it takes 5 1/2 years on average in Massachusetts for patients to be awarded money. During that time, caregivers often are told not to discuss the case with anyone, especially the patient.
Patients who accept the financial settlement surrender their right to sue, but those who decline the settlement can pursue legal action.
The hospitals that will test the initiative include Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Needham, Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Milton, Baystate Medical Center in Springfield, Baystate Franklin Medical Center in Greenfield, Baystate Mary Lane Hospital in Ware, and Massachusetts General Hospital.
Anyone, including doctors, nurses, patients, and families, can report a suspected error. The hospital will conduct a “root cause analysis’’ to determine if caregivers or hospital policy or systems were at fault. If they were, caregivers will apologize, and the hospital will work with hospital and physician malpractice insurers to determine the amount of compensation to offer the patient for injuries and follow-up care.
If a patient experiences an unpredictable reaction to a medication that caregivers could not foresee, that probably would not result in a settlement offer. But if a patient is harmed during surgery because caregivers did not ensure they were performing the correct operation, the patient would be entitled to compensation.
To increase trust in the system, hospitals will encourage patients to hire a lawyer to evaluate whether an offer is fair. If patients are not satisfied with a proposed settlement, they retain their right to sue the hospital and caregivers. Researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health will evaluate the results of the pilot program.
The Massachusetts coalition is pushing for legislation that will help it implement the changes, including a mandatory six-month “cooling-off period’’ after an error occurs before a patient can file a lawsuit. The coalition also wants to make caregiver apologies inadmissible in the event of a lawsuit, as a way to further encourage contrition.
The state Governor included both measures in legislation he filed last spring to control health care costs, and the coalition is lobbying for the measures to be included in House and Senate bills expected to be filed soon.
The coalition plans to propose legislation that would shield doctors from blame for mistakes attributed to hospital policy. If a physician is at fault, settlements would be part of that physician’s public record with the Massachusetts Board of Registration in Medicine and the National Practitioner Data Bank.
Mistakes caused by hospital policy are public through the Department of Public Health and would remain so. Now, settlements paid out by a doctor’s malpractice carrier are part of the physician’s public record,whether the doctor caused the error or not.
The coalition, which developed the road map with a $300,000 federal grant, has drawn heavily from a plan adopted by the University of Michigan Health System 10 years ago. The system’s widely respected approach of disclosure, apology, and settlement offer did not increase lawsuits and litigation costs as many providers feared.
The number of lawsuits filed per month dropped by one-half, and the time to resolve all claims fell from one year and four months to less than a year, according to a 2010 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine by researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. Spending on legal defense fell 60 percent.
Settlement offers to patients harmed at the University of Michigan have reached millions of dollars, similar to what a seriously injured person might win in court.
The president and founder of Medically Induced Trauma Support Services, a nonprofit organization for patients harmed during medical care -said it is important for patients participating in this new initiative to have attorneys to make sure the patient is getting what they are entitled to. The medical malpractice insurers have tons of attorneys on retainer.
Beyond that, the president and founder of Medically Induced Trauma Support Services, who became involved in patient advocacy after a life-threatening anesthesia accident she experienced at Brigham and Women’s in 1999, said patients also want emotional support. For some, that means participating in committees directing improvements at the hospital. Sometimes, it’s not about the money, they just want to be part of the change.’
A Baltimore medical malpractice attorney who represents patients, said he has concerns about the initiative. For the most part, malpractice insurers are looking for a discount from fair compensation’ by making an early offer. But if a patient’s rights are not limited in any way, there should be no issue with an attempt at early resolution. Cases just drag on for years.’
The coalition, which includes Baystate Health in Springfield, the Massachusetts Coalition for the Prevention of Medical Errors, and the Massachusetts Hospital Association, listed 12 obstacles to adopting the system, with “physician discomfort with disclosure’’ and fear of increased liability topping the list.
That is why a major component of the road map is education for hospital executives and trustees, caregivers, and the public.
Doctors and nurses have gotten better at disclosing errors in the past five years, as the success of the Michigan program spread. But efforts remain uneven.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Seven Massachusetts hospitals plan to offer patients harmed by medical errors a prompt apology and financial settlements before they resort to lawsuits, part of a major new initiative to improve the state’s cumbersome medical malpractice system.
A coalition of physician, hospital, and patient groups planned to release details Wednesday of the initiative, called “Road Map to Reform,’’ which they predict will increase reporting of medical mistakes and cut down on lengthy litigation that drives up health care costs and fuels distrust between caregivers and patients.
The plan calls on doctors and nurses to fully disclose mistakes to patients and apologize. Three large insurers and a medical group have donated about $1 million to underwrite the initial work at the seven test hospitals, and the coalition hopes to implement the improvements statewide over the next several years. This is a fundamental transformation of the system. The whole system has created secrecy and denial.
While many people believe doctors are ethically obligated to acknowledge mistakes, they are often hesitant to do so because they fear lawsuits. At the same time, doctors practice “defensive medicine’’ by giving unneeded tests so that in the event of legal action, they can show they did everything possible. When cases do end up in court, it takes 5 1/2 years on average in Massachusetts for patients to be awarded money. During that time, caregivers often are told not to discuss the case with anyone, especially the patient.
Patients who accept the financial settlement surrender their right to sue, but those who decline the settlement can pursue legal action.
The hospitals that will test the initiative include Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Needham, Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Milton, Baystate Medical Center in Springfield, Baystate Franklin Medical Center in Greenfield, Baystate Mary Lane Hospital in Ware, and Massachusetts General Hospital.
Anyone, including doctors, nurses, patients, and families, can report a suspected error. The hospital will conduct a “root cause analysis’’ to determine if caregivers or hospital policy or systems were at fault. If they were, caregivers will apologize, and the hospital will work with hospital and physician malpractice insurers to determine the amount of compensation to offer the patient for injuries and follow-up care.
If a patient experiences an unpredictable reaction to a medication that caregivers could not foresee, that probably would not result in a settlement offer. But if a patient is harmed during surgery because caregivers did not ensure they were performing the correct operation, the patient would be entitled to compensation.
To increase trust in the system, hospitals will encourage patients to hire a lawyer to evaluate whether an offer is fair. If patients are not satisfied with a proposed settlement, they retain their right to sue the hospital and caregivers. Researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health will evaluate the results of the pilot program.
The Massachusetts coalition is pushing for legislation that will help it implement the changes, including a mandatory six-month “cooling-off period’’ after an error occurs before a patient can file a lawsuit. The coalition also wants to make caregiver apologies inadmissible in the event of a lawsuit, as a way to further encourage contrition.
The state Governor included both measures in legislation he filed last spring to control health care costs, and the coalition is lobbying for the measures to be included in House and Senate bills expected to be filed soon.
The coalition plans to propose legislation that would shield doctors from blame for mistakes attributed to hospital policy. If a physician is at fault, settlements would be part of that physician’s public record with the Massachusetts Board of Registration in Medicine and the National Practitioner Data Bank.
Mistakes caused by hospital policy are public through the Department of Public Health and would remain so. Now, settlements paid out by a doctor’s malpractice carrier are part of the physician’s public record,whether the doctor caused the error or not.
The coalition, which developed the road map with a $300,000 federal grant, has drawn heavily from a plan adopted by the University of Michigan Health System 10 years ago. The system’s widely respected approach of disclosure, apology, and settlement offer did not increase lawsuits and litigation costs as many providers feared.
The number of lawsuits filed per month dropped by one-half, and the time to resolve all claims fell from one year and four months to less than a year, according to a 2010 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine by researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. Spending on legal defense fell 60 percent.
Settlement offers to patients harmed at the University of Michigan have reached millions of dollars, similar to what a seriously injured person might win in court.
The president and founder of Medically Induced Trauma Support Services, a nonprofit organization for patients harmed during medical care -said it is important for patients participating in this new initiative to have attorneys to make sure the patient is getting what they are entitled to. The medical malpractice insurers have tons of attorneys on retainer.
Beyond that, the president and founder of Medically Induced Trauma Support Services, who became involved in patient advocacy after a life-threatening anesthesia accident she experienced at Brigham and Women’s in 1999, said patients also want emotional support. For some, that means participating in committees directing improvements at the hospital. Sometimes, it’s not about the money, they just want to be part of the change.’
A Baltimore medical malpractice attorney who represents patients, said he has concerns about the initiative. For the most part, malpractice insurers are looking for a discount from fair compensation’ by making an early offer. But if a patient’s rights are not limited in any way, there should be no issue with an attempt at early resolution. Cases just drag on for years.’
The coalition, which includes Baystate Health in Springfield, the Massachusetts Coalition for the Prevention of Medical Errors, and the Massachusetts Hospital Association, listed 12 obstacles to adopting the system, with “physician discomfort with disclosure’’ and fear of increased liability topping the list.
That is why a major component of the road map is education for hospital executives and trustees, caregivers, and the public.
Doctors and nurses have gotten better at disclosing errors in the past five years, as the success of the Michigan program spread. But efforts remain uneven.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Defunct Doctor Dumps Private Records
Story first appeared in The Washington Post.
Overland Park, Kan.— More than 1,000 private abortion records from a defunct clinic have been found discarded in a recycling bin outside an elementary school near Kansas City, Kan., prompting a police investigation and outrage from people on both sides of the abortion debate. This could amount to a Wichita Medical Malpractice Lawyer investigating the data, which includes breach of doctor/patient confidentiality.
Overland Park, Kan.— More than 1,000 private abortion records from a defunct clinic have been found discarded in a recycling bin outside an elementary school near Kansas City, Kan., prompting a police investigation and outrage from people on both sides of the abortion debate. This could amount to a Wichita Medical Malpractice Lawyer investigating the data, which includes breach of doctor/patient confidentiality.
The patient records found Saturday came from
Affordable Medical and Surgical Services in Kansas City, Kan., which closed
after its doctor lost his medical license in 2005. The records detail names,
birth dates, telephone numbers, Social Security numbers and the patients'
health history, including if any abortions were performed, The Kansas City Star
reported. They included patients from almost every county in the Kansas City
area and beyond, from Topeka to Freeman, Mo.
This information lends itself to a very large invasion of privacy, and
possible medical negligence that aid a Wichita Medical Malpractice Lawyer in their case
against the defunct doctor in question.
Between 2000 and 2005, the doctor was either fined
or disciplined four times by the Kansas Board of Healing Arts and inspectors
who visited his clinic in 2005 and reported it was not clean. This leads to substandard care being a
possible factor, and again assists the ideas of a Wichita Medical Malpractice Lawyer
building a claim against the doctor.
The daughter of the woman who found the records
contacted the Kansas City Star after Overland Park police initially declined to
respond to her call. The women did not want their names released.
Overland Park police were investigating and other
agencies, including the Johnson County district attorney's office and the
Kansas Board of Healing Arts, were seeking information about the handling of
the documents to determine if they lend themselves to a Wichita Personal Injury Lawyer and their building case.
The doctor said he threw the personal documents into
recycling bins at Brookridge Elementary School on Friday. Kansas law requires that all medical records
be kept a minimum of 10 years. Hundreds of the discarded records were dated
after March 2002, The Star said. The defunct doctor said he dumped the records
because they were old and that he thought they would be picked up quickly. The
bins are emptied monthly.
The federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability
Act, or HIPAA, makes it a federal violation to release private medical
information without patient permission or other authorization. The law does not
dictate exactly how medical records should be destroyed but it specifically
prohibits discarding records in public dumpsters unless they have been made
unreadable.
It is unclear what actions might be taken against the
unscrupulous doctor. Medical providers that don't transmit payment or other
information to third-party payers electronically are not subject to HIPAA
regulations. On Monday, the doctor said his clinic was cash-only, although some
of the retrieved records clearly showed photocopies of insurance cards on the
back page, The Star reported.
Friday, January 13, 2012
Legitimate Medical Malpractice Lawsuits Are Not Being Reviewed in Connecticut
First appeared in Insurance Journal
After losing a baby because of an incompetent cervix, Patricia Votre thought she was well prepared when she got pregnant again. She made arrangements with her doctors to consult with high-risk pregnancy experts from Yale University and to have the specialists take over her care.
But when she began having problems including a fever and back pain, her doctors refused to turn over her care to the Yale experts, failed to treat her according to the Yale group’s recommendations and even hid the experts’ care plan from her, according to a lawsuit she filed in 2006. Her son, Miles, nearly died at birth from an E. coli infection and lived for 51 days before succumbing to a blood infection in 2003.
Despite the serious allegations, Votre was never able to get her case before a jury. A judge dismissed her lawsuit based on a technicality added to the state’s medical malpractice law in 2005 as part of the national “tort reform” debate. It requires plaintiffs in all malpractice cases to get an opinion from a medical expert backing up their allegations before they can sue, but legal fights over the credentials of those experts have led to many cases being dismissed.
“It was just not right. It was just not fair,” said Votre of Woodbridge, Conn., who’s now 41 and the mother of two children ages 7 and 12. “They used the law to manipulate the situation. It wasn’t about my baby. It was about me.”
Although the law was aimed at preventing frivolous lawsuits and reducing high malpractice insurance rates, it’s had the unintended consequence in many cases of keeping seemingly legitimate lawsuits out of Connecticut’s court system, an Associated Press review has found. The worst part, plaintiffs say, is that doctors, nurses, dentists and other medical professionals end up not being held accountable for their mistakes. Milwaukee Medical Malpractice Lawyers handled similar issues.
Since the law took effect, the number of malpractice cases filed in the state has dropped 20 percent to an average of 292 per year from an average of 364 annually, state records show. It’s not clear how much of the decrease can be attributed to the opinion letter requirement, but malpractice lawyers believe the mandate has played a big role.
“The argument is made that these (opinion letters) preclude the filing of a frivolous claim,” New Haven attorney Joel Faxon said. “It’s all just fear-mongering. It’s an impediment to bringing a case that gives them (defendants) a leg up.”
Faxon said there is already a malpractice lawsuit screening process that’s been effective for years. Most lawyers won’t file lawsuits unless there is very strong evidence of malpractice because the cases are expensive to litigate, he said.
Similar laws have been declared unconstitutional in several other states including Washington, Arkansas, Ohio and Oklahoma, mainly because the opinion letters can cost thousands of dollars and can prevent people who can’t afford them from getting their day in court, according to the Center for Justice & Democracy at New York Law School. But, lawyers for doctors and hospitals say, plaintiffs’ lawyers usually assume the cost of the letter as part of their fees, and plaintiffs will eventually need to pay an expert to testify at trial. Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer professionals help with all issues.
The wording of Connecticut’s statute says that experts who write opinions for plaintiffs must have “similar” credentials to those of the medical professionals accused of malpractice, and the opinion letters must be attached to lawsuits when they are filed.
But state judges have interpreted the law to mean that the experts must have credentials that are identical to those of the defendants. Many cases have been dismissed because the opinion writers’ certifications didn’t match up exactly with those of the defendants.
Both Democratic and Republican state lawmakers, who approved the 2005 law under pressure from doctors and hospital officials complaining about high malpractice insurance rates, say that’s not what they intended and they tried to ease the opinion letter requirements in the 2011 legislative session. The bill was passed by the House but died in the Senate at the end of the session, under heavy opposition from doctors and hospital officials.
“I don’t think anyone should be barred from the courthouse doors before the merits are heard,” said Republican state Sen. John Kissel of Enfield. “The party’s that’s forgotten in all of this is the injured individual who is suffering because of what he or she believes in medical malpractice.”
Kissel expects lawmakers in the 2012 session to take up another bill that would relax the opinion letter mandate. And an appeal filed with the state Supreme Court in a malpractice case is challenging the constitutionality of the law.
Lawyers for doctors and hospitals, however, say the law has been effective at weeding out frivolous claims and reducing their clients’ litigation costs, and they would continue to oppose any efforts to change the statute.
Eric Stockman, a New Haven attorney who has represented both plaintiffs and defendants in malpractice cases, said state law before 2005 required lawyers who filed malpractice lawsuits to declare in writing that the cases had merit.
“There was really no way to challenge whether that inquiry (by plaintiffs’ lawyers) was done,” Stockman said.
Since the 2005 opinion letter law took effect, “We really stopped seeing those really bad cases,” he said, referring to frivolous claims. Grand Rapids Medical Malpractice Lawyer professionals do not see claims as frivolous.
Stockman also said he believes part of the effort to relax the opinion letter requirements is to protect plaintiffs’ lawyers from legal malpractice claims that could arise if they don’t get the right expert to write the letter and their clients’ cases are dismissed.
One malpractice case that was dismissed because of the opinion letter requirement played a prominent role in this year’s legislative debate after having led to a landmark state Supreme Court ruling.
Richard Bennett Sr. of New Milford crashed his car while having a diabetic seizure in November 2006. He was brought to the New Milford Hospital, where his blood sugar was stabilized and he was given medication for back pain before being discharged.
But a doctor failed to diagnose the spine and leg fractures Bennett suffered, and Bennett died two months later of a heart condition caused by severe pain from the injuries, according to a lawsuit filed by Bennett’s family. The retired machinist was 69.
The lawsuit went all the way to the state Supreme Court, which last January upheld dismissals of the Bennetts’ case by lower courts because the author of the Bennetts’ opinion letter was a trauma surgeon and the defendant was an emergency room doctor. Virginia Beach Medical Malpractice Lawyer professionals help clients with similar cases.
But the Supreme Court did allow Bennett’s family to refile the lawsuit, which remains pending. The ruling, however, set a landmark precedent that upheld the opinion letter law, including its requirement that cases be dismissed if the opinion letters aren’t sufficient.
“It just defied logic,” said the Bennett family’s lawyer, Andrew Pianka. He added that the 2005 law is “actually being implemented … in a manner to defeat valid claims.”
Doctors and hospital officials insist that tort reforms including the opinion letters, known as “certificates of merit,” have helped lower malpractice insurance rates, and they don’t believe the measures have created barriers to the courts.
“It makes no sense at all to allow someone to file a medical malpractice lawsuit without the most superficial of investigations,” said Dr. David S. Katz, a general surgeon in Milford, Conn., and former president of the Connecticut State Medical Society.
“There has to be a least a basis from a qualified expert as to whether malpractice occurred or not,” he said. “There has to be a screening process and I think it’s a smart way to go.”
But the Center for Justice & Democracy recently released a report, echoing previous studies, saying that certificates of merit and other tort reforms have no effect on malpractice insurance rates. The report says rate levels go up and down based on insurance companies’ financial performance and the economy.
“The certificate of merit is weeding out legitimate cases,” said Joanne Doroshow, executive director of the center.
In Patricia Votre’s case, she sued her doctors for alleged breach of contract and infliction of emotional distress — not malpractice. But a judge ruled that her case involved alleged medical malpractice and dismissed her lawsuit because she never filed an opinion letter from a medical expert. The state Appellate Court upheld the ruling, and the state Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
In an ironic twist, Votre said her case set a precedent for dismissing malpractice cases.
“I feel that my son is made a mockery of at this point,” she said. “I can’t even explain to you what he went through. Now his memory is being trashed.”
Edmund Lohnes of Denver said he nearly died in 2007 because of a medical mistake at a New Haven hospital when staff gave him a drug to which he was allergic, despite his wearing a red wristband alerting staff to the allergy. He also sued, but his lawsuit was dismissed because the doctor who wrote his opinion letter was a pulmonologist while the defendant was licensed to practice emergency medicine. A Houston Medical Malpractice Lawyer dealt with a similar case earlier this year.
“I’m not going to be able to hold this doctor and the hospital accountable,” Lohnes said. “It affects the whole gauntlet of what I thought America was all about.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)