Original Story: detroitnews.com
Midland — Just days after the historic decision by the nation's High Court legalizing same-sex marriage, a Midland County district judge is refusing to perform any marriages. A Cleveland civil rights lawyer is following this story closely.
Judge Michael Carpenter of 75th District Court turned away a couple seeking to get married in the 87-year-old county courthouse, according to County Clerk Ann Manary. She said she was told of Carpenter's decision earlier this week.
"People can read between the lines," Manary told The Detroit News on Wednesday about the judge's decision. "Politically I'm not going to comment on Mr. Carpenter's decision, but he needs to comment on it. Sounds like (people) aren't happy about it." A Denver civil rights lawyer is experienced in the effective resolution of civil rights lawsuits as related to discrimination or mistreatment of any kind.
The Chief Judge for Midland County Trial Courts, Stephen Carras, along with two other Midland area judges, said in a statement Friday they will perform marriage ceremonies.
"The People of Midland County elected us to uphold the Constitution and laws of this land," said Carras, 42nd Circuit Court Judge Michael J. Beale and Probate & Juvenile Court Judge Dorene S. Allen. "We will continue to fulfill that responsibility by making sure that the public can still go to District Court to make wedding arrangements."
"Weddings are a great source of joy and hope for the future, and our court is honored to help families grow and prosper in our community," the judges said in the statement.
Carpenter is the sole district judge in Midland. There are two circuit court judges and one probate court judge in the county of 86,000 residents.
Manary, who married two same-sex couples after the U.S. Supreme Court decision that lifted the gay marriage ban in Michigan and three other states making same-sex marriage legal nationwide, said she will continue to marry couples at the County Services Building about a block from 75th District Courthouse. Carpenter's decision is directed at heterosexual couples as well.
"I will work with the judges to figure out an alternative," Manary said. "We will make sure no one is disenfranchised and they can still get married (by a judge.)" A Newark civil rights lawyer represents clients involved in civil rights matters including human rights, personal rights, and gay and lesbian rights.
In the meantime, Manary said, she is happy to issue licenses and perform marriages for couples.
In Michigan, county clerks are allowed to marry couples in addition to district judges, magistrates and clergy. Probate judges and circuit court judges need to have special assignment from the court administrative office in Lansing to be able to perform marriage ceremonies.
Carpenter told The Midland Daily News he is not required to perform wedding ceremonies. He added that he didn't have the staffing or time to perform the ceremonies. A spokesman for the Michigan courts office which oversees Michigan judges confirmed the judge is not required to do so.
The judge has not returned a call from The Detroit News seeking comment on his decision but he told the Midland Daily News he read the High Court's decision and reviewed his court rules, realizing judges aren't required to officiate at marriages.
Carpenter said he decided to stop conducting marriages as one of several cost-cutting moves after staffing cuts.
The judge's refusal to conduct marriage ceremonies has drawn swift reaction across the state. The MetroHealth Pride Clinic is the first in the region devoted to serving the health needs of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) community.
The organization Progress Michigan urged Attorney General Bill Schuette, who lives in Midland County, to "use his influence as Michigan's top law enforcement official to speak out in opposition to" Carpenter's decision.
"Judge Carpenter's decision to halt all marriages after the Supreme Court's ruling is clearly an attempt to defy marriage equality, which is an affront to our democratic institutions and is another attempt to discriminate against the LGBT community," said Lonnie Scott, executive director of Progress Michigan.
Showing posts with label Same-Sex Marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Same-Sex Marriage. Show all posts
Monday, July 6, 2015
Monday, November 10, 2014
FED APPEALS COURT RULES FOR GAY MARRIAGE BAN IN MICHIGAN
Original Story: detroitnews.com
The Michigan couple at the center of the same-sex marriage debate vowed Thursday to "continue the fight" after a federal appeals court in Cincinnati upheld the state's gay marriage ban.
"We're going to fight for the rights of our children and do whatever it takes to ensure our children have rights here in Michigan," April DeBoer, one of the plaintiffs in the case, said during a press conference Thursday evening surrounded by a room of supporters in Ferndale.
The U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals also upheld laws prohibiting gay marriage in Ohio, Tennessee and Kentucky, breaking ranks with other courts that have considered the issue and setting the stage for review by the U.S.Supreme Court.
"There are so many people in Ann Arbor and Lansing who are gathering behind us saying little prayers hoping this goes forward," said Jayne Rowse, DeBoer's partner. "We are so proud to represent you."
Carole Stanyar, co-counsel for the couple, said the U.S. Supreme Court could decide as soon as January whether to hear their appeal, which she plans to file in two weeks.
Stanyar, who argued the case before the appeals court in August, said the Michigan case could be precendent-setting for the country because it has gone to trial.
The three-judge appellate panel split 2-1 with Judge Jeffrey Sutton writing the majority opinion.
Sutton said it was pointless "to invalidate laws every time a new and allegedly better way of addressing a policy emerges."
Judge Deborah Cook concurred.
Dissenting Judge Martha Craig Daughtrey, who made her support of same-sex marriage known during the trial, slammed Sutton and Cook for taking what she called a "wait and see" approach, noting women still wouldn't have equal rights if other courts had adopted similar reasoning.
"If we in the judiciary do not have the authority, and indeed the responsibility, to right fundamental wrongs left excused by a majority of the electorate, our whole intricate, constitutional system of checks and balances, as well as the oaths to which we swore, prove to be nothing but shams," wrote Daughtrey.
At issue was the constitutionality of the so-called Michigan Marriage Amendment, passed by voters in 2004, which declares marriage is between "one man and one woman."
In March, after a nine-day trial in Detroit, U.S. District Judge Bernard Friedman ruled that Michigan's ban was unconstitutional because it denies same-sex couples equal protection under the law. A Cleveland Transgender Doctor is reviewing this case closely.
His ruling came after a lawsuit was brought by DeBoer and Rowse, two Hazel Park nurses raising, as a couple, children they had individually adopted. They sought to overturn the state's ban on same-sex marriage and the ban on joint adoption for gay couples.
Same-sex marriages are legal in 32 states and the District of Columbia. On Oct. 6 the U.S. Supreme Court issued orders that it would not review any of the seven marriage cases it had before it from five states that had appealed to the court for a review. That decision effectively made gay marriage legal in Indiana, Oklahoma, Utah, Virginia and Wisconsin.
In addition, the 9th Circuit, based in San Francisco, the 10th Circuit in Denver, the 4th Circuit in Richmond, Virginia, and the 7th Circuit in Chicago have all overturned statewide gay marriage bans in the South, the Midwest and the West since the summer.
Larry Dubin, a law professor at the University of Detroit Mercy School of Law, said it seemed as though the appeals court wanted to allow the Supreme Court to decide on the constitutionality of same-sex marriage.
"The court covers a lot of legal arguments, but in the end, gives deference to the voice of the voters of Michigan who passed the ban on same-sex marriage and the traditional definition of marriage being between a man and a woman," Dubin said. "This decision is a minority voice among all of the other courts that have reviewed this issue, and now this decision will likely go to the U.S. Supreme Court."
With the Supreme Court overturning the Defense of Marriage Act last year, Frank Aiello, a professor at Cooley Law School, said the justices may have hinted at how they would rule on the issue.
Same-sex couples such as Amanda and Kay Shelton were hoping for a different outcome.
"It's incredibly disappointing for hundreds of families," said Amanda Shelton, a Royal Oak attorney who is hoping to legally marry Kay. "I'm disappointed but not disheartened. This is not the end. We're not done yet."
Shelton called the court's ruling "absolutely ridiculous" since the "tide is changing" in other parts of the country where gay marriage bans have been lifted.
"This is an anomaly," she added. "I think the 6th Circuit is going to get smacked down by the U.S. Supreme Court."
But Michigan pastor Stacy Swimp was encouraged by the ruling.
"I'm very happy that the courts decided to uphold the voting rights of 2.7 million voters who under the Michigan and the U.S. constitutions exercised their voting rights," said Swimp of the National Christian Leadership Council and a member of the National Coalition of Black Pastors and Christian Leaders, which filed amicus briefs in the case opposing gay marriage. "No court had the right to usurp their God-given rights."
In its 64-page opinion, the appellate court also said the traditional perception of marriage cannot simply be overruled.
"A dose of humility makes us hesitant to condemn as unconstitutionally irrational a view of marriage shared not long ago by every society in the world, shared by most, if not all, of our ancestors, and shared still today by a significant number of states," the ruling states.
Attorney General Bill Schuette, who brought the appeal on Friedman's ruling, said he welcomes a Supreme Court review.
"The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit has ruled, and Michigan's constitution remains in full effect," Schuette said. "As I have stated repeatedly, the U.S. Supreme Court will have the final word on this issue. The sooner they rule, the better, for Michigan and the country."
The Michigan couple at the center of the same-sex marriage debate vowed Thursday to "continue the fight" after a federal appeals court in Cincinnati upheld the state's gay marriage ban.
"We're going to fight for the rights of our children and do whatever it takes to ensure our children have rights here in Michigan," April DeBoer, one of the plaintiffs in the case, said during a press conference Thursday evening surrounded by a room of supporters in Ferndale.
The U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals also upheld laws prohibiting gay marriage in Ohio, Tennessee and Kentucky, breaking ranks with other courts that have considered the issue and setting the stage for review by the U.S.Supreme Court.
"There are so many people in Ann Arbor and Lansing who are gathering behind us saying little prayers hoping this goes forward," said Jayne Rowse, DeBoer's partner. "We are so proud to represent you."
Carole Stanyar, co-counsel for the couple, said the U.S. Supreme Court could decide as soon as January whether to hear their appeal, which she plans to file in two weeks.
Stanyar, who argued the case before the appeals court in August, said the Michigan case could be precendent-setting for the country because it has gone to trial.
The three-judge appellate panel split 2-1 with Judge Jeffrey Sutton writing the majority opinion.
Sutton said it was pointless "to invalidate laws every time a new and allegedly better way of addressing a policy emerges."
Judge Deborah Cook concurred.
Dissenting Judge Martha Craig Daughtrey, who made her support of same-sex marriage known during the trial, slammed Sutton and Cook for taking what she called a "wait and see" approach, noting women still wouldn't have equal rights if other courts had adopted similar reasoning.
"If we in the judiciary do not have the authority, and indeed the responsibility, to right fundamental wrongs left excused by a majority of the electorate, our whole intricate, constitutional system of checks and balances, as well as the oaths to which we swore, prove to be nothing but shams," wrote Daughtrey.
At issue was the constitutionality of the so-called Michigan Marriage Amendment, passed by voters in 2004, which declares marriage is between "one man and one woman."
In March, after a nine-day trial in Detroit, U.S. District Judge Bernard Friedman ruled that Michigan's ban was unconstitutional because it denies same-sex couples equal protection under the law. A Cleveland Transgender Doctor is reviewing this case closely.
His ruling came after a lawsuit was brought by DeBoer and Rowse, two Hazel Park nurses raising, as a couple, children they had individually adopted. They sought to overturn the state's ban on same-sex marriage and the ban on joint adoption for gay couples.
Same-sex marriages are legal in 32 states and the District of Columbia. On Oct. 6 the U.S. Supreme Court issued orders that it would not review any of the seven marriage cases it had before it from five states that had appealed to the court for a review. That decision effectively made gay marriage legal in Indiana, Oklahoma, Utah, Virginia and Wisconsin.
In addition, the 9th Circuit, based in San Francisco, the 10th Circuit in Denver, the 4th Circuit in Richmond, Virginia, and the 7th Circuit in Chicago have all overturned statewide gay marriage bans in the South, the Midwest and the West since the summer.
Larry Dubin, a law professor at the University of Detroit Mercy School of Law, said it seemed as though the appeals court wanted to allow the Supreme Court to decide on the constitutionality of same-sex marriage.
"The court covers a lot of legal arguments, but in the end, gives deference to the voice of the voters of Michigan who passed the ban on same-sex marriage and the traditional definition of marriage being between a man and a woman," Dubin said. "This decision is a minority voice among all of the other courts that have reviewed this issue, and now this decision will likely go to the U.S. Supreme Court."
With the Supreme Court overturning the Defense of Marriage Act last year, Frank Aiello, a professor at Cooley Law School, said the justices may have hinted at how they would rule on the issue.
Same-sex couples such as Amanda and Kay Shelton were hoping for a different outcome.
"It's incredibly disappointing for hundreds of families," said Amanda Shelton, a Royal Oak attorney who is hoping to legally marry Kay. "I'm disappointed but not disheartened. This is not the end. We're not done yet."
Shelton called the court's ruling "absolutely ridiculous" since the "tide is changing" in other parts of the country where gay marriage bans have been lifted.
"This is an anomaly," she added. "I think the 6th Circuit is going to get smacked down by the U.S. Supreme Court."
But Michigan pastor Stacy Swimp was encouraged by the ruling.
"I'm very happy that the courts decided to uphold the voting rights of 2.7 million voters who under the Michigan and the U.S. constitutions exercised their voting rights," said Swimp of the National Christian Leadership Council and a member of the National Coalition of Black Pastors and Christian Leaders, which filed amicus briefs in the case opposing gay marriage. "No court had the right to usurp their God-given rights."
In its 64-page opinion, the appellate court also said the traditional perception of marriage cannot simply be overruled.
"A dose of humility makes us hesitant to condemn as unconstitutionally irrational a view of marriage shared not long ago by every society in the world, shared by most, if not all, of our ancestors, and shared still today by a significant number of states," the ruling states.
Attorney General Bill Schuette, who brought the appeal on Friedman's ruling, said he welcomes a Supreme Court review.
"The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit has ruled, and Michigan's constitution remains in full effect," Schuette said. "As I have stated repeatedly, the U.S. Supreme Court will have the final word on this issue. The sooner they rule, the better, for Michigan and the country."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)