Showing posts with label Foreclosure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foreclosure. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Wilbur Ross’s Mortgage Company Faces Servicing Suits

Bloomberg

 
 
Billionaire Wilbur Ross’s American Home Mortgage Servicing Inc., facing lawsuits by attorneys general in two states, was sued by a homeowner who accused the firm of using tactics that lead to improper foreclosures.

The lawsuit, filed Oct. 25 in federal court in Dallas, seeks class-action status on behalf of homeowners with mortgages serviced by American Home going back to 2006. American Home’s “illegal, unfair and deceptive business practices victimize borrowers” across the U.S., according to the complaint.

American Home “routinely and systematically assesses unwarranted fees against consumers, resulting in premature default that often gives rise to unfair and improper foreclosure proceedings,” according to the complaint.

Banks and loan servicers are under scrutiny for their foreclosure practices following accusations they relied on faulty documentation to foreclose on people’s homes. Attorneys general in all 50 states have launched a coordinated investigation into the issue.

The complaint in Dallas, filed by Kay VanHauen of Sanger, Texas, follows lawsuits by Greg Abbott, the state’s attorney general, and Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray. They separately sued American Home, based in Coppell, Texas, for alleged violations of consumer protection laws.

‘Without Merit’


“While a lawsuit on occasion may identify a legitimate servicing error, most of which are isolated and none of which to our knowledge indicate any systematic process flaws or patterns or unlawful behavior, we believe the majority of them are without merit,” Philippa Brown, a spokeswoman for American Home, said today in a phone interview.

Ross, 72, is chief executive officer of WL Ross & Co., a company that specializes in reorganizing distressed companies. He founded the New York-based company in 2000 after overseeing the bankruptcy practice at Rothschild Inc.

WL Ross bought American Home from its bankrupt lender parent in 2008, and later added operations and servicing contracts from H&R Block Inc., Citigroup Inc. and Taylor, Bean & Whitaker Mortgage Corp. Servicers collect payments from homeowners, negotiate loan modifications and foreclose on properties when borrowers default.

In an Oct. 23, 2008, interview with Bloomberg Radio, Ross said American Home was the second-largest servicer of subprime mortgages in the U.S. and was “eager” to continue expanding. The company has servicing operations in Irvine, California, Jacksonville, Florida, and Pune, India, according to its website.

‘Unconscionably One-Sided’

In his lawsuit, the Ohio Attorney General said American Home required borrowers to sign loan modifications, forbearance agreements and security-retention agreements that contain “illegal and unfair provisions and are unconscionably one- sided” in the company’s favor. American Home also provided “incompetent, inadequate and inefficient customer service,” lost documents and failed to respond to requests by borrowers for assistance, according to the complaint.

“The acts of some mortgage servicers have gone beyond the point of being negligent -- they have become predatory financial practices and in Ohio, they won’t be tolerated,” Cordray said in a statement on Nov. 5, when the lawsuit was filed.

Default Increase

The Texas Attorney General said in his lawsuit that American Home fails to properly credit homeowners for payments made on their mortgages; falsely claims borrowers didn’t make payments in order to justify late fees; and refuses to accept payments allegedly because a borrower is in default, thereby adding more late charges. The result, Abbott said, is to render homeowners in default on their mortgages.

“The cumulative effect of the foregoing acts and practices was to place more homes into foreclosure than there should have been,” Abbott said in the Aug. 30 lawsuit.

American Home is among 30 banks and mortgage companies that Abbott wrote to on Oct. 4, demanding they halt foreclosures in the state until they ensure that foreclosures that relied on faulty documents “will be rectified” and that future foreclosures are done with “legally correct documentation.”

American Home has been reviewing its procedures and is placing “tighter controls” on document signing and notarization, according to the attorney general’s office. The company found “a very limited number of cases” in which a person signing a document may not have done so in the presence of a notary, according to the attorney general.

Misapplied Payments

The lawsuit by VanHauen, the Texas homeowner, mirrors allegations made by the attorney general. American Home, she said, misapplied mortgage payments on two loans in September 2008 and improperly assessed fees and other charges. After notifying American Home about the problem, the company refused to correctly apply the payments. It treated the loan as being in default and initiated foreclosure proceedings, according to the complaint.

American Home also charged her for a homeowner insurance policy she didn’t need and charged her for property taxes she was paying to the county, according to the complaint. VanHauen proposed that her lawsuit cover homeowners who have similar complaints against American Home.

American Home has faced similar allegations in other lawsuits. In an April lawsuit filed in federal court in Baltimore, Michael and Ingrid Landi of Frederick, Maryland, accused American Home of falsely claiming in October 2009 that they had not made mortgage payments. American Home has asked the court to dismiss the complaint.

San Diego Suit

In a complaint filed in May in federal court in San Diego, American Home was accused of foreclosing on a home while it was discussing a loan modification with the owner, Kenneth Coplin. Coplin said in his complaint that American Home assured him it didn’t intend to foreclose or sell the property “in an effort to conceal” its intention to “mislead” him and “steal” the property.

Brown, the American Home spokeswoman, said the lawsuit was dismissed. The most recent entry on the court docket shows the case would be dismissed if Coplin failed by Oct. 25 to file certain documents related to serving the complaint. Coplin couldn’t be reached for comment.

Friday, October 22, 2010

Niche Lawyers Spawned Housing Fracas

The Wall Street Journal

Lawyer Michael Gaier switched his focus to foreclosure defense.
 
 
The paperwork mess muddying home foreclosures erupted last month. But the legal strategy behind it traces to a lawyer's gambit in 2006 that has helped keep one couple in their home six years beyond their last mortgage payment.

Lillian and Robert Jackson stopped paying on their home in Jacksonville, Fla., in 2004 when business dropped off at their cleaning company. Eviction might have seemed inevitable when they faced a foreclosure hearing two years later.

But their lawyer, James Kowalski, had the idea of taking a deposition from the signer of the mortgage papers. When a document processor for GMAC Mortgage admitted she routinely signed such papers without being familiar with details of the loans, she was tagged as one of a species now known as robo-signers.

It was a first step in the growth of a legal sub-specialty called foreclosure defense that has sown confusion and turmoil in the housing market. Lawyers in the field now commonly use a technique more identified with corporate litigation: probing depositions, designed to uncover any lapses in judgment, flaws in a process or wrongdoing. In the 23 states where foreclosures entail a court hearing, the bank may be ordered to pay the homeowner's legal bill if a lawyer can convince a judge that the bank has submitted false documents, such as affidavits saying employees personally reviewed the details of loans when they didn't.

The housing-market uncertainty stemming from the foreclosure fracas is unabated, despite moves by Bank of America Corp. and GMAC to resume some suspended foreclosure sales. In Florida, with over half a million foreclosure cases, banks that are reviewing their documentation have canceled hundreds of court hearings in recent weeks. Big banks that have said they are finding few or no flaws in the foreclosure process have encountered skepticism from some of the state attorneys general probing the mess, and those authorities are pushing ahead.

The great majority of delinquent borrowers don't hire lawyers but leave the home right before getting evicted. Some lawyers who represent financial institutions take a dim view of the growing ranks of lawyers pushing for a different outcome.

"There is a movement afoot by [state attorneys general] and private lawyers to use technical problems to avoid foreclosures where the borrower is in default and the foreclosure is in all respects substantively appropriate. These are lawyers where the best job they can do for their clients is to keep them in their houses without paying the mortgage," said Andrew L. Sandler, a Washington securities lawyer who represents banks and firms that service mortgages.

Mr. Sandler added: "The class-action lawyers are swarming around this issue right now, because they perceive that it can result in significant fees for them. But they're not well-founded cases, and the banks will vigorously contest any class action around these issues."

The big risk to banks and the housing market, indeed, is that more homeowners and lawyers come to see such cases as attractive to fight.

Mr. Kowalski in Jacksonville has already filed a suit seeking class-action status, in circuit court in St. Johns County, Fla., naming Deutsche Bank AG and Citigroup Inc. mortgage unit Citi Residential Lending, accusing them of violating Florida laws and seeking nonmonetary relief. On Tuesday, a New Jersey law firm filed a damage suit in federal court in New Jersey accusing Bank of America of breaching contracts with borrowers at settlement.

A spokesman for Citi called the suit "without merit." B of A declined to comment. Deutsche Bank didn't have any immediate comment.

It isn't clear how significant the suits ultimately will be. Lenders say paperwork problems can easily be fixed, and foreclosures can proceed. "The homeowner might get to live in the house for a few more months free. But these people do not have a right to a free house," said Laurence E. Platt, an attorney who represents mortgage lenders.

The suits, probes and foreclosure freezes are the culmination of a legal drama that has been unfolding, largely unnoticed by the public, since the case against the Jacksons was thrown out in 2006 by Florida state-court Judge Bernard Nachman.

He ordered GMAC Mortgage, a unit of Ally Financial Inc., to pay the $8,000 fee of the Jacksons' attorney after finding GMAC had filed false testimony, an affidavit in which a document signer, Margie Kwiatanowski, said she had personal knowledge of the details of loans such as the Jacksons'. GMAC declined to make Ms. Kwiatanowski available for an interview.

The judge also ordered GMAC to confirm that it had changed its policies to make sure anyone signing a document on its behalf read and fully understood the instrument. "Do not sign unless you have that comfort level," a GMAC memo then advised employees. "Do not sign verifications on court pleading documents unless you have independently checked the facts."

GMAC, which serviced the Jacksons' loan but didn't hold the mortgage, said: "As a servicer we try to avoid foreclosure whenever possible and work with the borrower on forbearance and home-preservation options before pursuing foreclosure." The firm wouldn't comment on cases still to be litigated.

GMAC also said it is reviewing all mortgages it services to make sure documents are properly prepared. It has never re-filed the case involving the Jacksons' house.

The Jacksons, still living there, are seeking a settlement. "What we want to do is to take the foreclosure off the credit report and dissolve it completely, so we can refinance the home and start over," said Ms. Jackson, 57.

In 2009, three years after the Jackson ruling, other Florida lawyers got into the act. Unaware of that case, a small law firm called Ice Legal took a deposition from another GMAC employee, who also testified to routinely signing foreclosure documents without reviewing the loans.

That testimony came about because the small law firm's founder, Thomas Ice, was searching for a way to help his bankruptcy clients.

Mr. Ice founded his firm in 2008 to focus on consumer bankruptcy, after a career at big law firms defending companies against plane-crash and SUV-rollover suits. With his wife, Ariane, a paralegal, he set up Ice Legal in a strip mall in Royal Palm Beach, Fla., next to a dentist.

As the economy frayed, bankruptcy clients appeared. Mr. Ice would help them with Chapter 13 filings that enable individuals, with a judge's blessing, to get rid of credit-card, car-payment and other debt. But the law doesn't let judges reduce someone's mortgage.

Searching for a way to defend clients facing foreclosure, Mr. Ice began researching English case law and the history of property rights. He ran across Sheldon v. Hently, a 1680 case that said an indebted merchant owed his debt to the person who had lent him the money, not to a debt collector who came around bearing a note.

While the English case didn't bear specifically on his work, it got Mr. Ice thinking about the concept of ownership of a debt, he says. A little more than a year after opening his firm, in the case of Boca Raton woman facing foreclosure, he decided to depose the GMAC employee who had actually signed documents concerning her indebtedness.

It was while grilling that employee, Jeffrey Stephan, that the firm discovered faulty documentation was more common than people had realized. Mr. Stephan testified he regularly signed more than 10,000 court affidavits a month without doing the required review of loan files.

Mr. Stephen also mentioned the name of his boss: Ms. Kwiatanowski, the woman whose failure to review loans before signing off had enabled the Jackson family in Florida to escape foreclosure for years.

Mr. Ice mentioned the deposition testimony to a fellow lawyer, Matthew Weidner. "Tom and I were talking, and it was, 'Jesus, they're like robots!'" Mr. Weidner says.

Mr. Weidner is also a blogger, and on Jan. 8 he wrote a blog post with an appellation for the routine signers. "We know from depositions taken of these 'robo signers,'" he wrote, "that they don't even read the documents placed in front of them and the notaries and witnesses that are supposed watch them as they sign are not present."

A GMAC spokeswoman, asked how Mr. Stephan could have submitted such affidavits years after a company memo had admonished employees to check the facts, said: "Obviously the policy wasn't being followed, and we discovered this procedural error. We became aware of the breakdown recently." Mr. Stephan couldn't be reached for comment. The woman in the Boca Raton case remains in her home.

Mr. Ice, recounting the suit and the legal steps he took, said it shows "the need for the complex litigation that is required to win these foreclosure cases."

Mr. Stephan re-emerged in June, in a case that helped spark the current foreclosure turmoil. A pro bono lawyer in Maine, Thomas Cox, took another deposition from Mr. Stephan, who again acknowledged routinely signing documents without reviewing the loans.

GMAC tried to sanction the lawyer on grounds he had embarrassed its employees, a maneuver that could have kept him from using the Stephan deposition as evidence. The motion was denied by Maine's Ninth District state court, which also ruled, late last month, that GMAC had submitted the Stephan affidavits "in bad faith." The court ordered GMAC to pay Mr. Cox $27,000, a sum it said he might have earned for his legal work if he hadn't been working pro bono.

GMAC suspended its foreclosure sales in 23 states in September and widened the freeze in October, before saying on Monday that it would again push forward with some of them. It has been replacing court affidavits that Mr. Stephan signed with documents signed by others.

At Ice Legal in Royal Palm Beach, attorneys are working through a load of several hundred foreclosure cases. Mr. Ice has hired three new lawyers and says he's so busy he has stopped playing golf and spends most of his time at the office. The firm has deposed alleged robo-signers at three other lenders or mortgage-serving companies besides GMAC.

Michael Gaier, on of the top lawyers in Philadelphia, switched to foreclosure defense last year after years of representing patients in malpractice suits and consumers who said they had purchased faulty products. His new legal practice "is academically challenging, and I'm hoping it'll be financially rewarding. I'm hoping the banks rewrite the mortgages, cover my fees. That's my end game," said Mr. Gaier.

Mr. Kowalski, the lawyer who in 2006 unearthed a robo-signer before that term was common, said, "I don't think the [mortgage] servicers ever thought that their process was going to see the light of day. It's just that so many of us have taken so many of these so far, that now, in 2010, we finally have some traction."

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Banks Face Mortgage Scrutiny as $49 Billion in Value Vanishes‏

Bloomberg

 
 
Citigroup Inc., Bank of America Corp. and Wells Fargo & Co., set to report earnings this week, face investors groping for answers after evidence of flawed foreclosure documents triggered a selloff of U.S. bank stocks.

The banks plus JPMorgan Chase & Co. saw $49.3 billion in market value shaved off in the three days ended Oct. 15 amid concern that rising costs of faulty foreclosures will eat into profits. JPMorgan set aside $2.3 billion of reserves to cover mortgage repurchases or litigation expenses, including some for “mortgage-related matters,” the lender said Oct. 13.

“We’ve had two banks report good earnings in terms of credit-quality costs coming down,” said Erik Oja, an equity analyst at Standard & Poor’s in New York, referring to JPMorgan and First Horizon National Corp. “But people don’t care. They say ‘Well, how many foreclosures do you have in the pipeline? And what are you seeing?’ And they answer that we’re looking at each one. And people say ‘All right, sell.’”

An investigation by attorneys general in all 50 states into foreclosure practices has fueled speculation that banks will have to purchase billions of dollars in loans from mortgage-bond investors who will challenge the paperwork. Lenders have suspended foreclosures in some states and started reviews after court documents surfaced showing employees at several large mortgage firms signed papers without ensuring their accuracy.

Oja cut his recommendation on Charlotte, North Carolina- based Bank of America to “hold” from “strong buy” on Oct. 15 because of uncertainty about mortgage costs.

Dimon’s ‘Blip’

JPMorgan Chief Executive Officer Jamie Dimon, 54, faced analysts’ questions about foreclosures on the company’s third- quarter conference call Oct. 13. Dimon said the New York-based lender probably will pay an “incremental” sum to review and fix foreclosure documents.

“If you’re talking about three or four weeks, it will be a blip in the housing market,” Dimon told investors. “If it went on for a long period of time, it will have a lot of consequences, most of which will be adverse on everybody.”

Analysts differ in their cost estimates. Compass Point Research and Trading LLC’s Chris Gamaitoni estimated in August that lenders may suffer as much as $179.2 billion in losses tied to soured mortgages they will be forced to repurchase from mortgage-bond insurers and investors. Last week, Mike Mayo, an analyst at Credit Agricole Securities USA in New York, estimated a cost of $20 billion for repurchases when including government- sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s Richard Ramsden said a worst-case scenario would be $84 billion, while Paul Miller, an analyst at FBR Capital Markets in Arlington, Virginia, said it could cost the banks as much as $91 billion.

‘A Lot of Uncertainty’

“There’s a lot of uncertainty surrounding what the eventual cost of mortgage repurchases will be,” Deutsche Bank AG analysts led by Matthew O’Connor wrote in a note last week. “The bad news is we (and the banks) won’t know the answer for some time. The good news is the banks should have time to absorb the losses.”

Bank of America, JPMorgan and Wells Fargo have the most at stake, O’Connor wrote.

Citigroup today said third-quarter profit rose to $2.17 billion, beating analyst estimates, as it reduced loan-loss reserves. The New York-based bank set aside $322 million to repurchase mortgages, compared with $347 million in the second quarter. Bank of America, which has halted foreclosure sales in 50 states, is scheduled to report third-quarter results tomorrow, and San Francisco-based Wells Fargo will announce results Oct. 20.

‘Messy Process’

The four banks control more than 55 percent of the market for billing and collections on U.S. home loans, according to Barclays Capital Inc. When borrowers default, the firms handle the foreclosure process.

Wells Fargo, which said it is proceeding with foreclosures, may have litigation and repurchase expenses of $15 billion over the next four years, according to Anthony Polini, a banking analyst at Raymond James & Associates Inc.

“Litigation expenses are going to be high,” Polini said in a phone interview. “Foreclosures are a messy process and one that will provide a headwind to earnings, but it doesn’t mean this recovery is postponed. It just means it happens at a slower pace.”

‘Grossly Distorted’


Barbara Desoer, 57, head of home lending at Bank of America, said Oct. 15 that estimates of added costs from foreclosures have been “grossly distorted.” The bank, the largest in the U.S. by assets, stands by the accuracy of its process, she said in an interview.

Mark C. Rodgers, a spokesman for Citigroup, said in an e- mailed statement last week that the bank has safeguards in place to prevent improper filings. Wells Fargo has enacted an additional review of pending foreclosures in 23 states to provide “further assurance” that information is correct, a spokeswoman, Vickee Adams, said last week.

Bank of America dropped $1.54, or 11.4 percent, in the three days ended Oct. 15, while Citigroup fell 29 cents, or 6.8 percent, the biggest three-day drop for the stocks since July. Wells Fargo declined $2.39, or 9.2 percent, the largest such falloff since May. JPMorgan fell $3.25, or 8 percent, over the same three days, the worst such period since the three days ended Jan. 22.

The market value of the 24 lenders in the KBW Bank Index fell by a combined $58.5 billion in the three days, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

“People are trying to sort out who’s going to bear the costs,” said James Barth, a professor of finance at Auburn University in Alabama and senior finance fellow at the Milken Institute in Santa Monica, California. “Someone has to pay for this, and that’s going to be the lenders.”

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Banks Restart Foreclosures

The Wall Street Journal

 
 
Two major lenders at the center of the foreclosure crisis took steps Monday to put the mess behind them by restarting home seizures that were frozen by documentation concerns.

Bank of America Corp. reopened more than 100,000 foreclosure actions, declaring that it had found no significant problems in its procedures for seizing homes. GMAC Mortgage, a lender and loan servicer, said that it also is pushing ahead with an unspecified number of foreclosures that came under intense pressure.

Monday's moves are part of a growing counterattack by lenders scrambling to stem a financial and political threat over allegations that certain employees signed hundreds of documents a day without carefully reviewing their contents when foreclosing on homes.

Bank of America, the nation's largest bank in assets, which imposed on Oct. 8 a nationwide moratorium on the sale of foreclosed homes, said it has begun preparing new affidavits for pending foreclosures in 23 states where a judge's approval is required. The paperwork will be submitted to courts by next Monday, and foreclosure sales will resume in those states starting in November, according to the bank.

"This is an important first step in debunking speculation that the mortgage market is severely flawed," said Bank of America spokesman James Mahoney. More details will be disclosed when the company reports quarterly results Tuesday.

Citigroup Inc. Chief Financial Officer John Gerspach said the bank has found no reason to halt foreclosures, calling its internal procedures "sound." "We have not identified any system issues," he said Monday.

Restarting the nation's foreclosure machine puts the lenders on a collision course with state attorneys general, who announced last week a nationwide investigation of foreclosure practices. Some state officials have been pushing for a wider halt to foreclosure sales, but Bank of America's moves show determination by at least some lenders to get back to business while the investigation proceeds.

A Bank of America spokesman said the bank has found "no cases" thus far of foreclosures that should not have "gone through." Last week, James Dimon, J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. chairman and chief executive, said that no one has been "evicted out of a home who shouldn't have been."

Some top attorneys general said they have little confidence that problems with foreclosures have been fixed. "We've been in discussions with some of the major servicers, and as part of that they've assured us that they are fixing this problem, but we're not just going to take their word for it," said Patrick Madigan, a spokesman for Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller.

It will be hard for lenders to declare the foreclosure crisis over and get back to business as usual. Bondholders are escalating efforts to recover losses on soured mortgage-bond deals containing loans with flawed paperwork. Meanwhile, federal banking regulators are assigning additional employees to an ongoing review of large mortgage-servicing operations, according to people familiar with the situation. Officials want to make sure that documentation procedures are being followed and companies are meeting all legal foreclosure requirements.

Bank stocks surged Monday as investors reassessed last week's outlook for the cost of the foreclosure mess. Citigroup shares jumped 23 cents, or 5.8%, to $4.18 a share in New York Stock Exchange composite trading at 4 p.m., on better-than-expected earnings. Bank of America rose 36 cents, or 3%, to $12.34, while J.P. Morgan was up $1.05, or 2.8%, to $38.20.

Bank of America is the only major U.S. bank that announced a halt to all foreclosure sales while it reviewed documents for errors. Bank officials say they're readying new affidavits for 102,000 pending foreclosure actions.

A company spokesman said the largest investors in mortgages serviced by Bank of America have signed off on the new timetable. The bank will continue delaying foreclosure sales in the 27 states where court approval isn't required until a review is completed "on a state by state basis." The bank expects delays on fewer than 30,000 foreclosure sales nationwide.

"Now it may be legal, but I am not sure it's ethical," said Robert Quigley, a 68-year-old retired commercial fisherman, who received a legal notice last week that Bank of America is proceeding with foreclosure on his home in Lake City, Fla. A bank spokesman said the bank never said it would stop all foreclosure proceedings, just final sales.

GMAC, a unit of Ally Financial Inc., declined to comment on the number of foreclosures it has reviewed so far, but said they included loans with affidavits signed by employee Jeffrey Stephan. His testimony in a deposition that he signed 10,000 foreclosure affidavits a month without reviewing the underlying documentation led GMAC to halt evictions in 23 states last month while it scrutinized its procedures.

Several lawyers representing borrowers facing foreclosure by GMAC said affidavits signed by Mr. Stephan were replaced by similar filings with the signature of a different employee.

Michael Holmes, an antiques dealer in Belfast, Maine, thought he would get a chance to save his home because the affidavit used by GMAC to substantiate his loan amount was signed by Mr. Stephan. Instead, GMAC replaced Mr. Stephan's document in the courthouse file for the foreclosure proceeding with an affidavit signed by employee Davida Harriott. Her name also appears on substitute paperwork in pending foreclosure cases in Florida, according to court documents and lawyers representing the borrowers.

Gina Proia, a spokeswoman for Ally, said on Monday: "As each case is reviewed and remediated, it moves on." None of the revised foreclosure documents being filed by the company will bear the signature of Mr. Stephan, though he still works for GMAC, she said. Mr. Stephan and Ms. Harriott couldn't be reached for comment.

Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray, who last week filed a lawsuit against GMAC alleging hundreds of counts of fraud related to foreclosure documents, said he is suspicious of efforts to replace paperwork. "Substituting new evidence in [cases] where there's been fraud won't help prevent the court from sanctioning them for the fraud that has already been committed," he said. "It doesn't unring the bell."

Thursday, October 14, 2010

States to Probe Mortgage Mess

The Wall Street Journal

 
 
A coalition of as many as 40 state attorneys general is expected Wednesday to announce an investigation into the mortgage-servicing industry, an effort some of them hope will pressure financial institutions to rewrite large numbers of troubled loans.

The move comes amid recent allegations that mortgage-servicers, which include units of major banks such as Bank of America Corp., submitted fraudulent documents in thousands of foreclosure proceedings nationwide.

The banks say the document problems are technical—largely the result of papers approved by so-called robo-signers with little review—and don't reflect substantive problems with foreclosures. Still, they have drawn criticism from consumer advocates and state and federal lawmakers.

"I think the mortgage-servicing firms need to understand that they face real exposure now, and they would be well advised to take this very seriously, to clean this up by doing loan workouts to keep people in their homes, which up till now they've just paid lip-service to," said Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray.

Some in Congress have called for a moratorium on all foreclosures until the documentation issue is resolved, though senior Administration officials Monday again declined to endorse that idea. Servicers that have lied to courts by filing incorrect paperwork "need to suffer the consequences for their irresponsible actions," said Shaun Donovan, the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. But "where we have not found problems with particular servicers…we do have some risk of going too far."

The attorneys' general immediate aim is to determine the scale of the document problems and correct them. But several of them have said that the investigation could force the lenders and servicers to agree to mass loan modifications or principal forgiveness schemes. Other possibilities include financial penalties or changes in mortgage servicing practices.

Lenders and servicers have largely resisted reducing principal on mortgages, instead focusing on interest-rate reductions or term extensions. Banks say they are worried about lawsuits from investors, some of whom could lose money in a principal write down.

Former New Jersey attorney general Peter Harvey, now a trial lawyer in New York, said that a settlement with state attorneys general would likely "to give the banks some cover" to make changes that might otherwise result in lawsuits by investors in mortgage-backed securities.

The mortgage servicers had little to say in response to an impending multi-state probe. "We will work with the attorneys general to address the concerns they have expressed," said Dan Frahm, a spokesman for Bank of America.

"We look forward to cooperating with the attorneys general," said a spokesman for J.P. Morgan Chase & Co., which has suspended foreclosure sales and evictions in 23 states in response to questions about it use of robo-signers. A spokesman for Citigroup said the company, has "no reason to believe our employees have not been following" proper procedures in processing foreclosures. A spokeswoman for GMAC Home Mortgage Inc, a unit of Ally Financial, Inc, said it continued to review its loan documents.

The number of servicing companies that will be included in the probe hasn't been determined.

Iowa attorney general Thomas Miller, who is leading the effort, said his office might take cues from an investigation brought by Massachusetts attorney general Martha Coakley. She successfully pressured Bank of America Corp. in March to reduce mortgage-loan balances by as much as 30% for thousands of borrowers, using the threat of a lawsuit to get a settlement, though documentation problems were not at issue then.

The primary weapon the states could wield would be their respective laws against unfair and deceptive acts and practices, said Prentiss Cox, a professor of law at the University of Minnesota and former Assistant Attorney General in Minnesota.

Those laws are easier to apply, however, when a lender misleads a borrower than in pursuing problems with foreclosures related to documentation, he said. Individual attorneys general could also bring actions under states' various foreclosure laws.

Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan said she was preparing to introduce legislation meant to tighten foreclosure laws and prevent document errors in the future. She also is pushing federal representatives to resurrect a bill that would allow bankruptcy judges to "cram down," or cut, a troubled homeowner's mortgage debt.

"The immediate goal is to stop fraudulent foreclosure and to require that the lenders and servicers are following the law. But that's the bare minimum. That's what they have to do to follow the law," she said.

Nearly a dozen attorneys general nationwide, including Ms. Coakley and Mr. Miller, have called on lenders and servicers to suspend foreclosures until document irregularities are studied and corrected.

Top lawyers from multiple states have gone after mortgage lenders before. In 2008, Bank of America Corp. settled charges brought by 15 attorneys related to accusations of predatory lending in its Countrywide Financial Corp. unit, granting loan modifications worth $8.4 billion to thousands of homeowners.

Mr. Cordray, of Ohio, last week became the first attorney general to sue a mortgage servicer, when he filed suit against GMAC Mortgage LLC. The suit also named as a defendant GMAC employee Jeffrey Stephan, an alleged "robo-signer," who said that he signed off on thousands of court documents related to foreclosures without reading them first.

GMAC announced that it was suspending foreclosures in the 23 U.S. states where judges are required to sign off on them after news of Mr. Stephan's activities surfaced. J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.'s Chase Home Mortgage unit suspended judicial foreclosures soon after, and Bank of America followed suit. On Friday, Bank of America widened its foreclosure freeze to all 50 states.

Some attorney generals would like to look beyond the narrow issues raised by the robo-signing. The issue "I'm most engaged in right now is the big servicers who are initiating foreclosures while the borrower is in the modification process," said Arizona Attorney General Terry Goddard.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Attorneys General in 40 States Said to Join on Foreclosures

Bloomberg

 
 
Attorneys general in about 40 states may announce by next week a joint investigation into potentially faulty foreclosures at the largest banks and mortgage firms, according to a person with direct knowledge of the matter.

State attorneys general led by Iowa’s Tom Miller are in talks that may lead to the announcement of a coordinated probe as soon as Oct. 12, said the person, who asked not to be named because an agreement wasn’t completed. The number of states may change because several are deciding whether to join, the person said. New Mexico Attorney General Gary King said yesterday in a statement that his office will join a multi-state effort.

Lawyers representing the banks expect a widening investigation, according to Patrick McManemin, a partner at Patton Boggs LLP, a Washington-based law firm that represents banks, loan servicers and financial institutions. Bank of America Corp., the biggest U.S. lender, yesterday extended a freeze on foreclosures to all 50 states.

“We are aware of or involved in a large number of investigations that lead us to believe there are in the neighborhood of 40 state attorneys general who have initiated investigations or expressed an interest,” McManemin said in a telephone interview.

Justice Department

Officials in at least seven states have already announced probes into claims that employees at home lenders and loan servicers signed court documents without ensuring the information was accurate. On Oct. 7, Miller said in a statement that he was working with state officials, banking regulators and the U.S. Justice Department to launch a coordinated review. Attorneys general in Ohio and Connecticut have said some of the practices may amount to fraud.

The Senate Banking Committee plans to hold a hearing Nov. 16 to investigate mortgage servicing and foreclosure practices, according to its website.

“American families should not have to worry about losing their homes to sloppy bureaucratic mismanagement or fraud,” the panel’s chairman, Connecticut Democrat Christopher Dodd, said in a statement. “Regulators at the federal, state and local levels have a responsibility to uphold the law and protect consumers from unfair foreclosure.”

Frozen Foreclosures


Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Ally Financial Inc. already froze foreclosures in 23 states where courts supervise home seizures, amid allegations that employees used unverified or false data to speed the process. Litton Loan Servicing LP, a mortgage-servicing business owned by Goldman Sachs Group Inc., said yesterday it’s halting some foreclosures to review how they’re handled.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, a Democrat from Nevada, called on other banks and mortgage firms to follow Bank of America’s lead and “review their practices to ensure that they are not unfairly targeting homeowners in Nevada and across the nation,” according to a statement yesterday.

“There are reasons for these procedures and those are to make sure the banks own the homes they are foreclosing on,” Robert Lawless, a professor at the University of Illinois College of Law in Champaign, said in a telephone interview. “At the same time I don’t think it is going to be a tidal wave of relief for homeowners. My bet is that there will be a delay.”

Vickee Adams, a spokeswoman for San Francisco-based Wells Fargo & Co., and Mark Rodgers, a spokesman for New York-based Citigroup Inc., said the companies were still processing foreclosures. Thomas Kelly, a spokesman for New York-based JPMorgan, and Gina Proia, spokeswoman for Detroit-based Ally, declined to comment.

Homes Taken


Lenders took possession of a record 95,364 homes in August and issued foreclosure filings to 338,836 homeowners, or one of every 381 U.S. households, according to RealtyTrac Inc., an Irvine, California-based data vendor.

“If you have a national moratorium on foreclosures, that’s a problem,” Paul Miller, an analyst for FBR Capital Markets Corp. in Arlington, Virginia, said in a phone interview. “The longer you drag out foreclosures the longer it takes to get through” the housing slump, he said.