Showing posts with label presidential candidate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label presidential candidate. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Case Was Doomed and Weak

Story first appeared in Business Week.
Original story contributed by Associated Press.

thumbnail
A jury's refusal to convict a former presidential candidate was less a redemption of the former White House hopeful than a rejection of the Justice Department's boldest attempt to make an example of someone in the name of enforcing campaign finance laws.

Thursday's verdict of not guilty on one count and a mistrial on five others bore out criticism from the earliest stages of the case that it was a reach, that prosecutors went after the ex-U.S. senator without the kind of evidence that justified the charges that he masterminded a scheme to use campaign donations to hide his pregnant mistress from the public and his terminally ill wife.

As noted by nearly every campaign finance lawyer who considered the matter, this was a lousy case. All the salacious details prosecutors offered up to prove that the defendant is, indeed, despicable, were not enough to persuade the jury to convict him.

Several jurors said there just wasn't enough evidence. On network talk shows Friday, even jurors who thought he was guilty on at least some counts said the prosecution wasn't able to prove it.

The defendant faced six felony charges involving nearly $1 million provided by two wealthy political donors that was used to help hide the Democrat's mistress as he sought the White House in 2008. He faced a maximum sentence of up to 30 years in prison if convicted on all counts.

To convict, prosecutors needed to show not only that the candidate knew about the secret payments, which he denied, but that he knew he was violating federal law by accepting them. But the government was unable to produce any witness who said he knowingly violated the law. Even a former aide testified that the defendant told him he had consulted campaign finance lawyers who assured him the money was legal.

As former trial lawyer, the defendant was so unimpressed with the testimony against him that when the government rested, he turned to a member of his defense team and asked dismissively, "That's their case?"

When it was their turn, his lawyers presented just two days of evidence.

This is a case that should define the difference between a wrong and a crime between a sin and a felony, stated the lead defense attorney. John Edwards has confessed his sins. He will serve a life sentence for those.

Presented with no damning evidence and no obvious victim beyond the public's trust, jurors couldn't see their way to convicting the charismatic ex-candidate. Prosecutors are unlikely to retry the case, a law enforcement official told The Associated Press on the condition of anonymity because the decision will undergo review in the coming days.

A former federal prosecutor and Raleigh defense attorney who attended the trial, said he thought the prosecutors took their best shot with what was ultimately a very weak case.

They got their best witnesses, their best evidence and the judge ruled in their favor on all major evidentiary issues. In the end, the jury just didn't believe them.

Another former federal prosecutor who watched the case from inside the courtroom, said the jury's verdict was not surprising, considering the government had no smoking gun to prove Edwards guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. But, he predicted, the defendant won't fare as well in the court of public opinion.

Regardless of the decision, he still is Exhibit A for how we do not want our leaders to behave. This is a huge victory for him, and big burden off his shoulders, but a hollow one given his astounding fall from grace.

From the start, lawyers for the defense had painted the prosecution as politically motivated.

The final decision to prosecute the defendant was made by the current Presidential administration and the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section. Once highly admired, the section's reputation suffered after a corruption conviction against former U.S. Senator of Alaska was overturned in 2009 after it was found prosecutors knowingly concealed exculpatory evidence and allowed false testimony to be presented at trial.

The case was tried by three prosecutors sent down from Washington and one prosecutor from Raleigh. They presented 14 days of testimony and evidence, with Young their star witness.

An aide once so loyal he falsely claimed paternity of the defendant's baby and helped hide his mistress from the media for nearly a year, he turned against his former boss and testified for the prosecution under an immunity agreement. Though the government's case recounted how the defendant repeatedly lied about his affair to both the American people and his cancer-stricken wife, the defense countered by shredding the aide's credibility on the witness stand and using financial records to show the former aide and his wife kept most of the money at issue in the case, funneling it into the construction of the couple's $1.6 million dream home.

Before the prosecution, no federal candidate had been tried over payments from a third party that flowed to a mistress. The lack of resolution in the case will likely leave candidates and regulators confused about what is and is not a legitimate campaign expense.

The U.S. criminal justice system requires fair notice of what is and is not against the law. Sadly, the Justice Department seems to have forgotten this fundamental American precept. Luckily, the jury remembered.


For more Law News, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For more national and worldwide Business News, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For more local and state of Michigan Business News, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For more Health News, visit the Healthcare and Medical News blog.
For more Electronics News, visit the Electronics America blog.
For more Real Estate News, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For more Advertising News, visit the Advertising, Marketing and Media blog.
For more Environmental News, visit the Environmental Responsibility News blog.
For information on website optimization or for the latest SEO News, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Monday, April 23, 2012

Opening Arguments Begin in Former Presidential Candidate Trial

Story first appeared in USA Today.

Prosecutors and defense lawyers in the trial of a former presidential candidate were poised to begin making their case to jurors on whether the man violated federal campaign finance laws.

Opening arguments were to begin Monday in Greensboro, N.C.

The defendant pleaded not guilty to six criminal counts related to nearly $1 million in secret payments from two wealthy supporters. Much of the money was used to hide the then-married politician's pregnant mistress during his 2008 White House campaign.

Prosecutors are expected to argue that he masterminded a conspiracy to conceal his affair. The defense lawyers contend the payments were gifts from friends intent on keeping the candidate's wife from finding out about the mistress and her baby. The defendant's wife died in December 2010 after battling cancer.

A U.S. District Court Judges, who was appointed in 2010 by the President, will preside. She said she expects the proceedings to last about six weeks.

A key issue will be whether the defendant knew about the payments made on his behalf by his national campaign finance chairman, the late Texas lawyer, and a now-101-year-old heiress and socialite who was a campaign donor. Each had already given the campaign the maximum $2,300 individual contribution allowed by federal law.

The defendant denies having known about the money, which paid for private jets, luxury hotels and medical care for the mistress. Prosecutors will seek to prove he sought and directed the payments to cover up his affair, protect his public image as a "family man" and keep his presidential hopes viable.

The well-known Washington lawyer who is representing him, has said that even had his client known about the secret payments, his actions wouldn't amount to a crime under federal law. The government's case relies on flawed legal reasoning, that the grand jury process was tainted and that the Republican federal prosecutor who led the investigation was motivated by partisanship.

The defense lawyer has derided what he calls the government's "crazy" interpretation of federal law whereby money that was never handled by the candidate nor deposited in a campaign account is being defined as campaign contributions.

Much of the money at issue was funneled to a former campaign aide once so close to the defendant that he initially claimed paternity of his boss's illegitimate child. The aide and his wife invited the pregnant mistress to live in their home near Chapel Hill and later embarked with her on a cross-country odyssey as they sought to elude tabloid reporters trying to expose the candidate's extramarital affair.

The campaign aid later fell out with the defendant and wrote an unflattering tell-all book, The Politician. The aid and the mistress recently ended a two-year legal battle over ownership of a sex tape the mistress recorded with the defendant during the campaign, agreeing to a settlement that dictates that copies of the video will be destroyed.

The aide is expected to be a witness for the prosecution, while the defense is likely to call the mistress to testify. Two of the lawyers who represented the mistress in her civil suit against the former aide joined the defendant's legal team last month. After years of adamant public denials, the defendant acknowledged paternity of the mistress' daughter in 2010. The girl, now 4, lives with her mother in Charlotte.

It has not yet been decided whether the defendant, a former trial lawyer once renowned for his ability to charm jurors, will testify in his own defense.


For law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the  Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.