Story first appeared in USA Today.
All the plaintiff wanted to do was share his Christian beliefs one on one with students at Tennessee Tech in Cookeville, according to Nashville Civil Rights Lawyers.
Instead, police asked him to leave campus because he didn't give the university notice two weeks ahead of time, and he didn't disclose what he wanted to talk about.
Now he has won a case before the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which ruled Tennessee Tech's policy was unreasonable and violated the First Amendment.
The decision could have implications for public colleges and universities throughout the region as officials balance public access with the need to keep students safe.
In light of the decision, public colleges and universities throughout the state would be wise to review their policies, said an executive director of the Nashville-based First Amendment Center.
People have a right to speak on public property, and the government can intrude only in the narrowest of ways.
Any time government asks us in advance to specify the kind of speech we are engaged in, that raises a warning flag for the courts. Government ought not to be in the business of saying what you can and can't say.
Tennessee Tech's associate vice president for communications, said the university could not comment on the case since it was sent back to the trial court. The lawsuit is seeking unspecified damages. Attorneys for the Tennessee Board of Regents are reviewing the federal appeals court decision.
The Tennessee Board of Regents— which oversees 46 institutions including Tennessee Tech — has adopted an updated campus-use policy that takes effect June 1. The policy reduces the notice period to five days, but a spokeswoman said it was in the works long before the appeals court ruling.
For the plaintiff, he hasn't been back to Tennessee Tech since he was there three years ago. He fears arrest, according to court documents.
He filed the lawsuit because he believes university officials used their open-ended discretion to discriminate against his particular message.
All he wanted to do, according to court records, was tell students about the hope that he believes Jesus Christ offers for humanity.
Sharing a message
The plaintiff travels to universities in the southeastern region and along the Atlantic coast, said a Memphis-based attorney and senior counsel at the Center for Religious Expression.
Over two days, he was bounced from one official to another as he sought permission to speak to Tennessee Tech students.
On April 6, 2009, he called Tennessee Tech about visiting the campus to share his message. He was told to stop by the student information office when he arrived, according to court records. A 14-day notice period was not mentioned.
The next day, he and a friend arrived and on their way to the office began speaking with students on the south patio, a pedestrian mall-like area where students gather near the University Center.
Once inside, a university official told him he could speak only on the north patio. There were fewer people and no tables and chairs there.
When he asked to see the campus policy limiting him to the north patio, the official became agitated and threatened to call university police, court records show.
After talking things over with his friend, the plaintiff went back inside the University Center. This time, he spoke with the dean of student affairs. He explained why the north patio wouldn't work. The south patio was better, and he wouldn't be a disruption.
While waiting for the dean to check university policy, he went back outside and continued to speak with students. A few minutes later, according to the court record, a university police officer asked him to leave or face arrest for trespassing.
On the second day, he again spoke to the dean of student affairs, this time by telephone. He learned he had to submit an application two weeks in advance. He believed that was too burdensome.
Instead, the plaintiff went to a sidewalk he thought was off Tennessee Tech's campus. About 15 minutes later, the dean of student affairs approached and warned McGlone he could not speak there without university permission.
Lawsuit filed
In March 2010, the plaintiff sued the university, arguing Tennessee Tech's actions over those two days and its campus-use policy violated his First Amendment rights.
The policy requires 14 business days' notice if someone wants to come onto campus. Applicants must provide information on a program's purpose and whether they will distribute literature.
In his lawsuit, he argued that he often likes to speak on the news of the day and the notice period was burdensome. He did not want to disclose his topics for fear it could be used to discriminate against him, records show.
The plaintiff lost at the trial court, which ruled he was not harmed by the university's actions and therefore could not sue. But he won a victory on appeal.
The federal appeals court, in its April 23 decision, said the desire to share his beliefs is protected First Amendment activity and the open areas of Tennessee Tech's campus are public forums.
When deciding to allow people on campus, the policies must not grant overly broad licensing discretion to government officials, the court said.
The appeals court said the two-week notice period is unreasonable, far longer than other timeframes upheld by federal courts.
Public institutions cannot impose overly broad, burdensome restrictions on non-disruptive speech, he said. Passing out religious literature on a sidewalk is quintessential public free speech.
For more law related news, visit the Nation
of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical
blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and
Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Showing posts with label Tennessee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tennessee. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 9, 2012
Thursday, July 29, 2010
City Attorney may face Criminal Investigation
Chattanooga Times-Free Press
City Attorney Mike McMahan might have to return hundreds of thousands of dollars of city money, risk losing his job for 10 years and face prosecution for fraud after a state comptroller's report said he violated state law, records show.
"I am of the opinion that a reasonable jury would find it implausible that the city's own attorney, who was siphoning off hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to his own private firm, did so ignorantly and without knowledge of and intent to benefit his own finances and the business interests of his private law firm," Chadwick W. Jackson, staff attorney for the state Comptroller's Office, wrote in a letter to City Auditor Stan Sewell.
Mr. McMahan said he has done nothing wrong.
"I am angry," Mr. McMahan said Friday about the report. "I really am angry. This calls my integrity into question. My integrity has never been questioned."
A longtime arrangement between the city and the city attorney's office was illegal and Mr. McMahan knowingly violated Tennessee law by billing more than $15,000 a month for secretarial services at his private law firm, according to the comptroller's report released on June 29.
Mr. Jackson said he forwarded his findings to Hamilton County District Attorney Bill Cox for review. Mr. Jackson said Mr. McMahan should face criminal prosecution for fraud.
Mr. Cox said his office is looking over the comptroller's recommendations for prosecution.
"I'm reviewing it at this point of time," he said.
Mr. McMahan, who as city attorney is paid $105,765 a year by the city, also billed the city nearly $200,000 a year for clerical and legal assistance from the staff of his law firm, McMahan & Associates. Mr. McMahan insists he never profited from the arrangement, which he said is allowed under professional services contracts. But auditors claim the payments to Mr. McMahan as a city department head violate the city's conflict-of-interest and purchasing rules.
CITY RESPONSE
Mayor Ron Littlefield lashed out at the state Comptroller's Office on Friday, saying no one from the office ever contacted him or anyone else within the city. He said the arrangements described as being illegal have been going on for 45 years and his office corrected them by making the city attorney's office an in-house department in November.
"We're essentially beating a dead horse," Mr. Littlefield said. "It's not like this was anything new or interesting."
The state comptroller reviewed the case after Mr. Sewell conducted an informal audit in September. That audit criticized the arrangement that allowed the city attorney to use his own law firm for city-paid services and to do outside legal work while on the city payroll. Mr. McMahan said last year he personally earned less than $10,000 from outside legal work.
The City Council voted May 25 to forward the city audit to the state Comptroller's Office for an independent opinion. The comptroller's opinion since has been forwarded to several council members, along with the mayor and Mr. McMahan.
Mr. McMahan said he was so frustrated after seeing the report that he tendered his resignation but the mayor would not accept it. He said Friday that the city is correcting the situation and he had only been following the practices of his predecessors, Randall Nelson and the late Gene Collins.
"If I thought it was illegal, I wouldn't be here," he said. "I wouldn't have taken the job."
The report points out that before bringing the city attorney's office and staff within city government last year, McMahan & Associates billed the city about $15,300 a month for secretarial services based upon fees set by Mr. McMahan. The city also paid 80 percent of the payments for the law firm's lease in the Pioneer Bank building and also paid for health insurance for the employees of McMahan and Associates even though most were not city employees.
Mr. McMahan said his predecessor used a private firm to bill the city for secretarial services. After being appointed city attorney in 2009, Mr. McMahan said he found that, if he did the billing himself, he could save the city money.
"It was well intentioned to save city money," Mr. McMahan said.
But in his audit review last year, Mr. Sewell said the arrangement allowed the city attorney to oversee money going into a company he owned and controlled.
It will be up to Mr. Cox's office to seek any kind of criminal charges.
The City Council also could try to push Mr. McMahan from office and sue him to get back any of the compensation received from the arrangements.
"Why has he not been removed from office and repaid all compensation his firm received?" Mr. Jackson asked in the report.
COUNCIL RESPONSE
Councilwoman Deborah Scott, who also received a copy of the report, said last week the findings are "concerning."
"The council and the district attorney have to make some decisions about that," she said. "We have to follow the law."
Councilman Peter Murphy, chairman of the Legal and Legislative Committee and an attorney himself, said he did not think the state attorney's finding is accurate. He said law offices have various ways of billing and the traditional way the city attorney's office billed the city fell within those parameters.
He also dismissed the idea of criminal wrongdoing, saying there is no evidence to suggest Mr. McMahan profited from conducting his billing while also operating as a private practice.
"There has to be intent for something to be criminal," Mr. Murphy said.
He also said that if the council went after Mr. McMahan's law firm to recoup money, the effects could be devastating. The staff attorneys in the office likely would quit if that were the case, he said, and the city could spend millions of dollars in a legal fight with its own attorneys.
"I think that would be very negative," Mr. Murphy said.
Mr. Littlefield reiterated Friday that the arrangement has been corrected. The city attorney and his staff have moved into the City Annex building and are now being paid fully as city employees, he said.
The report comes at the end of a practice that went on for nearly a half century and he stopped it, he said.
"No good deed goes unpunished," he said.
"I am of the opinion that a reasonable jury would find it implausible that the city's own attorney, who was siphoning off hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to his own private firm, did so ignorantly and without knowledge of and intent to benefit his own finances and the business interests of his private law firm," Chadwick W. Jackson, staff attorney for the state Comptroller's Office, wrote in a letter to City Auditor Stan Sewell.
Mr. McMahan said he has done nothing wrong.
"I am angry," Mr. McMahan said Friday about the report. "I really am angry. This calls my integrity into question. My integrity has never been questioned."
A longtime arrangement between the city and the city attorney's office was illegal and Mr. McMahan knowingly violated Tennessee law by billing more than $15,000 a month for secretarial services at his private law firm, according to the comptroller's report released on June 29.
Mr. Jackson said he forwarded his findings to Hamilton County District Attorney Bill Cox for review. Mr. Jackson said Mr. McMahan should face criminal prosecution for fraud.
Mr. Cox said his office is looking over the comptroller's recommendations for prosecution.
"I'm reviewing it at this point of time," he said.
Mr. McMahan, who as city attorney is paid $105,765 a year by the city, also billed the city nearly $200,000 a year for clerical and legal assistance from the staff of his law firm, McMahan & Associates. Mr. McMahan insists he never profited from the arrangement, which he said is allowed under professional services contracts. But auditors claim the payments to Mr. McMahan as a city department head violate the city's conflict-of-interest and purchasing rules.
CITY RESPONSE
Mayor Ron Littlefield lashed out at the state Comptroller's Office on Friday, saying no one from the office ever contacted him or anyone else within the city. He said the arrangements described as being illegal have been going on for 45 years and his office corrected them by making the city attorney's office an in-house department in November.
"We're essentially beating a dead horse," Mr. Littlefield said. "It's not like this was anything new or interesting."
The state comptroller reviewed the case after Mr. Sewell conducted an informal audit in September. That audit criticized the arrangement that allowed the city attorney to use his own law firm for city-paid services and to do outside legal work while on the city payroll. Mr. McMahan said last year he personally earned less than $10,000 from outside legal work.
The City Council voted May 25 to forward the city audit to the state Comptroller's Office for an independent opinion. The comptroller's opinion since has been forwarded to several council members, along with the mayor and Mr. McMahan.
Mr. McMahan said he was so frustrated after seeing the report that he tendered his resignation but the mayor would not accept it. He said Friday that the city is correcting the situation and he had only been following the practices of his predecessors, Randall Nelson and the late Gene Collins.
"If I thought it was illegal, I wouldn't be here," he said. "I wouldn't have taken the job."
The report points out that before bringing the city attorney's office and staff within city government last year, McMahan & Associates billed the city about $15,300 a month for secretarial services based upon fees set by Mr. McMahan. The city also paid 80 percent of the payments for the law firm's lease in the Pioneer Bank building and also paid for health insurance for the employees of McMahan and Associates even though most were not city employees.
Mr. McMahan said his predecessor used a private firm to bill the city for secretarial services. After being appointed city attorney in 2009, Mr. McMahan said he found that, if he did the billing himself, he could save the city money.
"It was well intentioned to save city money," Mr. McMahan said.
But in his audit review last year, Mr. Sewell said the arrangement allowed the city attorney to oversee money going into a company he owned and controlled.
It will be up to Mr. Cox's office to seek any kind of criminal charges.
The City Council also could try to push Mr. McMahan from office and sue him to get back any of the compensation received from the arrangements.
"Why has he not been removed from office and repaid all compensation his firm received?" Mr. Jackson asked in the report.
COUNCIL RESPONSE
Councilwoman Deborah Scott, who also received a copy of the report, said last week the findings are "concerning."
"The council and the district attorney have to make some decisions about that," she said. "We have to follow the law."
Councilman Peter Murphy, chairman of the Legal and Legislative Committee and an attorney himself, said he did not think the state attorney's finding is accurate. He said law offices have various ways of billing and the traditional way the city attorney's office billed the city fell within those parameters.
He also dismissed the idea of criminal wrongdoing, saying there is no evidence to suggest Mr. McMahan profited from conducting his billing while also operating as a private practice.
"There has to be intent for something to be criminal," Mr. Murphy said.
He also said that if the council went after Mr. McMahan's law firm to recoup money, the effects could be devastating. The staff attorneys in the office likely would quit if that were the case, he said, and the city could spend millions of dollars in a legal fight with its own attorneys.
"I think that would be very negative," Mr. Murphy said.
Mr. Littlefield reiterated Friday that the arrangement has been corrected. The city attorney and his staff have moved into the City Annex building and are now being paid fully as city employees, he said.
The report comes at the end of a practice that went on for nearly a half century and he stopped it, he said.
"No good deed goes unpunished," he said.
Monday, March 29, 2010
Tennessee Moves to Split Custody Evenly in Messy Divorce Cases
USA Today
Eric Kyle, a divorced father of two children, would like to spend more time parenting.
A Tennessee bill that would evenly split child custody in contentious divorce cases is drawing national attention and dividing groups along gender lines.
On one side is an alliance of women's groups, some judges and the Tennessee Bar Association, who say the change would make divorces tougher to settle and give abusive ex-husbands leverage they shouldn't have. Spending half of the time with each parent would also impose impractical schedules on kids, they say.
On the other side are fathers' rights groups who say kids get deprived of full relationships with both parents. Courts have too long ignored laws calling for custody decisions to be made in children's best interests, they say, and judges are overly influenced by notions about the mother-child bond.
The state's House Children and Family Affairs' Family Justice Subcommittee is scheduled to meet today to review divorce-related data it requested from the Tennessee Bar Association, as it works to determine whether to send the bill to a second committee that could send it to the full House.
Other states, including Missouri, start from a presumption of an even custodial split unless there has been abuse, said Janet Richards, a law professor at the University of Memphis who specializes in child custody matters. Tennessee would be alone in requiring clear, convincing evidence that one parent is unfit before dividing custody unequally, she said.
"This law sets up a standard of proof that's just short of the criminal standard of beyond a reasonable doubt," Richards said.
Committee hearings on the bill have drawn standing-room-only crowds full of mothers wearing saucer-size lapel stickers that read "Vote no on HB 2916" and fathers wearing everything from military fatigues to business suits.
Right now, parents divorcing in Tennessee — or unmarried parents trying to work out custody arrangements — are urged to work out a plan with a mediator. Under the pending bill, courts automatically would divide children's time equally between moms and dads who are unable to agree unless one parent can prove the other utterly unfit.
The way Eric Kyle sees it, he hasn't been able to properly father his children since his 2005 divorce.
Kyle, who lives in Davidson County, Tenn., wanted his son and daughter to split their time equally between him and his ex-wife, who lives in Williamson County, Tenn. But when Kyle sought divorce lawyers willing to try to negotiate that kind of arrangement, one after another told him the same thing.
"You either have to dirty up your ex and do whatever you have to to get full custody, or you accept what I understand is a pretty standard 80-20 time split," he said. "Of course, it's dads that get the children 20% of the time, in most cases."
Rep. Mike Bell, a Republican and the bill's key sponsor, said he introduced the bills after constituents' complaints and hopes it might encourage more parents to reconsider divorce.
"It's a concern that children are being deprived of one parent or another in most cases in a custody battle," said Bell, who has been married 25 years and has five children.
Opponents want to scare the public with claims about children being shuttled back and forth and attending multiple schools, said Mike McCormick, executive director of the Washington, D.C.-based American Coalition for Fathers and Children.
"I say — with the recognition that there is nothing like (this bill) in the country — all it would actually do is require parents to be on equal footing in courts of law," McCormick said. The bill ignores the problems some families have, said Kathy Walsh, executive director of the Tennessee Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence.
Some parents divorce after years of the kind of controlling, domineering or even violent behavior by one party that doesn't go away just because the relationship ends, Walsh said.
She said the bill could prompt victims to stay with their abusers so they don't have to leave their kids alone with the other parent.
Monica Gimbles said she doesn't think the bill is realistic. She is in the process of finding an attorney to work out custody arrangements for her 5-year-old daughter with her onetime fiancé.
"This is the kind of idea that people come up with when they haven't ever actually taken care of a child, a small child that needs a lot of care and takes a lot of time," Gimbles said. "It just makes the child's life topsy-turvy."
On one side is an alliance of women's groups, some judges and the Tennessee Bar Association, who say the change would make divorces tougher to settle and give abusive ex-husbands leverage they shouldn't have. Spending half of the time with each parent would also impose impractical schedules on kids, they say.
On the other side are fathers' rights groups who say kids get deprived of full relationships with both parents. Courts have too long ignored laws calling for custody decisions to be made in children's best interests, they say, and judges are overly influenced by notions about the mother-child bond.
The state's House Children and Family Affairs' Family Justice Subcommittee is scheduled to meet today to review divorce-related data it requested from the Tennessee Bar Association, as it works to determine whether to send the bill to a second committee that could send it to the full House.
Other states, including Missouri, start from a presumption of an even custodial split unless there has been abuse, said Janet Richards, a law professor at the University of Memphis who specializes in child custody matters. Tennessee would be alone in requiring clear, convincing evidence that one parent is unfit before dividing custody unequally, she said.
"This law sets up a standard of proof that's just short of the criminal standard of beyond a reasonable doubt," Richards said.
Committee hearings on the bill have drawn standing-room-only crowds full of mothers wearing saucer-size lapel stickers that read "Vote no on HB 2916" and fathers wearing everything from military fatigues to business suits.
Right now, parents divorcing in Tennessee — or unmarried parents trying to work out custody arrangements — are urged to work out a plan with a mediator. Under the pending bill, courts automatically would divide children's time equally between moms and dads who are unable to agree unless one parent can prove the other utterly unfit.
The way Eric Kyle sees it, he hasn't been able to properly father his children since his 2005 divorce.
Kyle, who lives in Davidson County, Tenn., wanted his son and daughter to split their time equally between him and his ex-wife, who lives in Williamson County, Tenn. But when Kyle sought divorce lawyers willing to try to negotiate that kind of arrangement, one after another told him the same thing.
"You either have to dirty up your ex and do whatever you have to to get full custody, or you accept what I understand is a pretty standard 80-20 time split," he said. "Of course, it's dads that get the children 20% of the time, in most cases."
Rep. Mike Bell, a Republican and the bill's key sponsor, said he introduced the bills after constituents' complaints and hopes it might encourage more parents to reconsider divorce.
"It's a concern that children are being deprived of one parent or another in most cases in a custody battle," said Bell, who has been married 25 years and has five children.
Opponents want to scare the public with claims about children being shuttled back and forth and attending multiple schools, said Mike McCormick, executive director of the Washington, D.C.-based American Coalition for Fathers and Children.
"I say — with the recognition that there is nothing like (this bill) in the country — all it would actually do is require parents to be on equal footing in courts of law," McCormick said. The bill ignores the problems some families have, said Kathy Walsh, executive director of the Tennessee Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence.
Some parents divorce after years of the kind of controlling, domineering or even violent behavior by one party that doesn't go away just because the relationship ends, Walsh said.
She said the bill could prompt victims to stay with their abusers so they don't have to leave their kids alone with the other parent.
Monica Gimbles said she doesn't think the bill is realistic. She is in the process of finding an attorney to work out custody arrangements for her 5-year-old daughter with her onetime fiancé.
"This is the kind of idea that people come up with when they haven't ever actually taken care of a child, a small child that needs a lot of care and takes a lot of time," Gimbles said. "It just makes the child's life topsy-turvy."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
