Showing posts with label Whistleblower. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Whistleblower. Show all posts

Monday, July 6, 2015

VICTIMS LINE UP FOR CANCER DOCTOR'S SENTENCING

Original Story: detroitnews.com

Geraldine Parkin will face cancer doctor Farid Fata in Detroit federal court on Monday morning, as she and 24 other victims or family members of victims prepare to make statements as part of the cancer doctor's sentencing hearing. A Detroit health care lawyer has experience with multiple industry types and implications of detrimental health care practices or incidents.

"For me, I want the pleasure of looking him in the eye," says Parkin, who says her husband, Tim Parkin, is largely disabled as a result of his treatment. Fata once looked into her eyes and those of her adult children, insisting that her husband needed chemotherapy. Now she is ready to respond.

"I want to say to him, 'You gave us a life of the unknown, of misery, and now you're going to have a life behind bars.' "

The hearing, which is expected to last all week, likely will conclude with Judge Paul D. Borman sentencing Fata, who faces life in prison for his crimes. About 150 victims filed victim impact statements with the court. A Detroit medical malpractice lawyer is following this story closely.

Fata's north Oakland County cancer treatment empire collapsed after his arrest two years ago. He pleaded guilty to 16 counts of fraud in September.

But fraud doesn't accurately describe Fata's crimes, victims and former associates say, and victims are being allowed to speak in open court. While that's common in other kinds of criminal trials, it's unusual in a sentencing proceeding for victims of Medicare fraud.

In this case, though, some of Fata's patients were given chemotherapy treatments, some for years, after false or inflated cancer diagnoses by Fata. Many others were treated, and billed for, drugs on schedules designed for profitability rather than therapeutic value. The government has estimated there are at leat 550 people who were victimized by the doctor.

"Whether they were cancer or non-cancer patients, solid tumor or liquid, Fata did not discriminate: his ultimate goal was to maximize his profit on the backs of his patients," federal prosecutors argued in a sentencing memorandum.

Fata has been compared by government lawyers to financial fraudster Bernard Madoff for the brazen scope of his crimes and his willingness to prey on those who trusted him. At least two expert medical witnesses for the government are scheduled to testify during the sentencing hearing. An expert for the defense who reviewed some of Fata's cases defended the treatment of 17 out of 20 cases — but could not defend the rest. A Detroit negligence lawyer is experienced in the effective resolution of negligence lawsuits as related to improper care or practice in a professional setting.

About 40 members of the victims' group are traveling to the courthouse in a chartered bus, wearing special T-shirts and buttons emblazoned with the slogan "Army of One," united in their quest for justice and their shared experience. Speakers are allotted 10 minutes each to make their statements.

But beyond the hearing, complex issues of compensation for the victims remain. About 40 lawsuits are pending in Oakland County Circuit Court. Borman will hold a restitution hearing at least 90 days after Fata's sentencing to adjudicate the distribution of assets. The government has claimed Medicare is owed $34 million.

In addition to Medicare and former patients, private insurance companies, including Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Michigan, and a former employee turned whistle-blower have a financial stake in the outcome.

Compensation even for the most devastated victims is not clear-cut. Some couldn't file lawsuits because the statute of limitations had expired by the time Fata was arrested, says Donna MacKenzie, of Olsman Mueller Wallace & MacKenzie, a Ferndale law firm handling 13 cases against Fata and his practice. Many others who were harmed were turned away, for various reasons, because of the cost of litigating their claims.

Brian McKeen, who represents other former patients, says Fata's practice was "drastically under-insured" for a total of $3.6 million. Victims say they've been told the government has recovered about $10 million in assets.

"I'm on a mission to make the public realize how heavily the justice system is skewed toward providers and against the plaintiffs, the victims," he said. "Nobody cares about victim's rights until they become a victim."

Fata's arrest was triggered two years ago, on August 2, 2013, when the clinic's practice business manager, George Karadsheh, notified the FBI of Fata's potential crimes. On Aug. 5, 2013, Karadsheh officially filed a so-called qui tam or whistle-blower lawsuit in federal court. The FBI then interviewed Dr. Soe Maunglay, an oncologist at the clinic who had reported his concerns to Karadsheh. Fata was arrested the following morning.

Karadsheh's identity became public June 10, when a Detroit News article named him as the Fata practice insider who first called the FBI. The government subsequently unsealed the lawsuit.

"I've handled a lot of Medicare fraud but this is unspeakable," says David Haron, Karadsheh's lawyer. "Mr. Karadsheh has incredible concern for the patients. He lost his job but they lost so much more."

Parkin, the wife of a victim, knows her family will never regain what they have lost. "For us, the hearing is important because we don't want this to go down in history as fraud," she says. "We want it to go down as murder."

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Penn State Stuck with Whistleblower Case

Story first appeared in USA Today.

The Penn State football assistant whose report of another assistant allegedly attacking a child in the showers led to the head coach's firing said in a court filing Tuesday that he is suing the school.

The "writ of summons" filed by the assistant coach's lawyer described it as a whistleblower case, but the brief document was not accompanied by a full complaint that would lay out the allegations.

The filing was first reported by the Centre Daily Times on its website.

The assistant coach, then a graduate assistant, has said he complained to the head coach of seeing the boy in a locker room shower naked with the defendant.

He testified in December that he believed the defendant was molesting the boy and having some type of sexual intercourse with him, but added he was not "100 percent" certain they were having intercourse because of his vantage point.

Penn State's trustees have said they fired the head coach partly because of his response to the incident. He had reported the matter to administrators, which trustees have called his minimum legal duty and a failure of leadership. He was fired as coach in November and died in January of lung cancer.

The assistant coach, who was a receivers coach, was placed on paid administrative leave by the school after the three men were arrested in November. All three have pleaded not guilty.

Penn State spokesman said that school officials were unable to comment because they had not seen the complaint.

Pennsylvania prosecutors said Monday they now believe the alleged shower assault took place a year earlier than they first claimed.

The attorney general's office said in a court filing that investigators concluded the alleged attack took place around Feb. 9, 2001. Previously filed court documents, including a grand jury report issued before the defendant's arrest dated it March 1, 2002.


For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the  Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Friday, April 27, 2012

Whistleblower Lawsuit Filed in Pontiac

Story first appeared in The Detroit Free Press.

The former construction manager for the City of Pontiac filed a whistleblower lawsuit Thursday, alleging the city's emergency manager and the head of the building department fired him after he alerted state and federal officials to what he said were bid-rigging and environmental violations. He is seeking more than $25,000 in damages.

The emergency manager and building department head are both named in the suit. Also named in the suit is Wade Trim Associates, a Detroit construction consulting firm where the building department head works. He is contracted out to the City of Pontiac.

The suit claims the defendant was hired in May, in part to help supervise the cleanup and demolition of some of the city's aging housing stock, according to Minneapolis Whistleblower Lawyers.

He said he became aware that the city was violating laws in how it handled demolitions and asbestos disposal. He said he reported the violations to the federal office of Housing and Urban Development and to the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality.

He also claims the building dept. head interceded in the city's bidding process to award business to a contractor who had been previously banned because of poor work.

The city was eventually cited for violations, the suit says. When the involved parties learned that the defendant had been reporting to state and federal agencies, they fired him, the suit says.

The involved emergency manager is well-known in municipal finance circles. Before the state governor appointed him as emergency manager in September, he was the executive administrator for the City of Warren. He also worked as the court-appointed receiver for the City of Ecorse, and the emergency manager for Hamtramck.


For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the  Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

Sprint Accused of Tax Fraud in NY State

Story first appeared in the Los Angeles Times.

Sprint Nextel Corp. is being sued for $300 million by the New York Attorney General, who is accusing the wireless carrier of tax fraud.

The suit alleges, based on a whistle-blower’s tip, that Sprint underpaid sales tax on some of its wireless plans for the last seven years – a “groundbreaking” filing.

The complaint alleges that Sprint’s debt to New York is growing by $210,000 a week. The NY Attorney General claims the company already owes more than $100 million. Under the state’s False Claims Act, Sprint could be forced to pay out three times that in penalties. New York Taxation Lawyers are following the case.

The legislation also could require a quarter of any future settlement to go to the as yet unnamed whistle-blower, whose March 2011 suit against Sprint sparked the attorney general’s investigation.

Sprint, in a statement, said the government’s suit is without merit and that it categorically denies the complaint’s allegations.

Spring maintains that they have collected and paid over to New York every penny of sales taxes on mobile wireless services that they believe the customers owe under New York state law.

Sprint’s argument is that New York should only tax calls on its flat-rate plans that originate and end within the state. The Attorney General said that the company is on the hook for the full amount of its monthly charges, and mentioned that Sprint’s competitors – including Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile – all have complied.

But since 2005, Sprint has repeatedly and knowingly submitted false records and statements to tax authorities and concealed this practice from taxing authorities, its competitors, and its customers, the attorney general’s office alleges.

The complaint claims that Sprint’s alleged tax dodging was an effort to obtain an advantage over its competitors by positioning its calling plans as cheaper options.

Tax dodging is not acceptable and every tool in the arsenal will be used to make sure that taxpayers’ money is protected, and that honest businesses and consumers are not placed at a disadvantage for collecting and paying their fair share of taxes.


For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the  Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

NEW CORPORATE WHISTLE-BLOWER PROGRAM UNDER FIRE

Original Article by New York Times.
A new front has opened in the behind-the-scenes battle over financial regulation.
Industry groups have been examining legal challenges to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s new corporate whistle-blower program and a provision surrounding the extraction of oil and natural gas from foreign countries, people briefed on the talks said. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s plan to curb speculative trading is also under fire.
The catalyst has been a federal appeals court decision in July striking down an S.E.C. rule that would have made it easier for shareholders to nominate company directors. The so-called proxy access rule stemmed from the Dodd-Frank act, the sweeping regulatory overhaul enacted in the wake of the financial crisis.
In recent weeks, lawyers and Wall Street trade groups have gathered in Washington to ponder the next big case. Lawyers branded one meeting, held by the United States Chamber of Commerce, as “Dodd-Frank Excesses,” according to two people who were notified of the meeting.
Until now, Wall Street relied largely on an army of lobbyists to chisel away at 300 new rules flowing from the S.E.C. and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, among other agencies. But while lobbying might yield the occasional loophole, judicial rulings can halt new rules altogether.
The lawyer who won the proxy case on behalf of the Chamber of Commerce said he would hope the agencies are taking to heart the potential consequences for Dodd-Frank rules.
Hal S. Scott, a professor at Harvard Law School and a director of the Committee on Capital Markets Regulation, a research group that has been a critic of Dodd-Frank, said he does see lots of challenges coming down the pike.
Regulators, reluctant to give in to industry pressure, are rushing to safeguard their rules from legal action. The commodity commission, having already delayed several Dodd-Frank rules for six months, is now studying the proxy case and considering adjustments to some proposed regulations, according to a person close to the agency. Earlier this month, the agency dispatched several staff members to meet with S.E.C. officials about the recent court decision.
For its part, the S.E.C. is weighing an appeal of the proxy ruling. The S.E.C. is also adding economists, planning to hire eight over the next two years, after the appeals court rebuked the agency for not fully evaluating the proxy rule’s economic effects.
The legal challenges are rooted in a 1996 law that requires the S.E.C. to promote efficiency, competition and capital formation. The law enabled the financial industry to build lawsuits around the economic costs of a rule, regardless of its merits.
In 2005, the Chamber of Commerce was the first business group to invoke the law, using it to successfully challenge certain S.E.C. rules for the mutual fund industry. The chamber later gained momentum with a string of similar victories in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Altogether, the appeals court has tossed out three financial regulations in the last six years, including the proxy rule.
Mr. Scalia, a partner at the law firm Gibson Dunn and the son of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, was on the winning end of each case.
Banks and corporations, rather than challenging the rules directly at the risk of alienating regulators, turn to seasoned litigators like Mr. Scalia and influential trade groups like the Chamber of Commerce to lead the fight. For more than 30 years, the chamber has had a separate litigation center, which operates as its own law firm in Washington.
The S.E.C.’s former general counsel who now works at the law firm Latham & Watkins sai it is usually not in the interest of a single business to mount a claim, and that you need some cut-out man or organization that speaks for broad groups.
The industry has shied from mounting a broader challenge to Dodd-Frank itself, finding it cheaper and easier to gradually chip away at the law’s fiercest provisions. Lawyers say a single lawsuit contesting the constitutionality of Dodd-Frank could take years — and millions of dollars — to wind through the courts, with little chance of succeeding.
By some measures, the proxy rule was an unlikely choice to challenge on economic grounds. The S.E.C. produced 60 pages on a cost-benefit analysis of the rule and spent 21,000 staff hours drafting it over two years, Mary L. Schapiro, the agency’s chairwoman, said in a recent letter to Congress.
That the proxy regulation still did not pass muster does not bode well for several other Dodd-Frank rules that received considerably less explication, sometimes only 25 pages, on their economic effects.
Financial trade groups, according to several lawyers, are now considering suits against the S.E.C.’s corporate whistle-blower office, which opened last week. The chamber, at least, argues that the whistle-blower program allows tipsters to undermine internal compliance departments.
Industry groups are also looking at claims against a few more obscure Dodd-Frank provisions. One S.E.C. regulation requires companies to disclose whether they manufacture goods using so-called conflict minerals like gold from Congo.
Tiffany & Company argued in a letter to the S.E.C. that the proposed rules “would violate the First Amendment,” laying the groundwork for business groups to mount a constitutional challenge.
Some letters are even blunter, as groups invoke the proxy case as a cautionary tale.
Royal Dutch Shell wrote the S.E.C. this month about our expected costs stemming from a proposal about oil extraction. Shell filed the letter, it said, in light of the recent decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals.
The commodity commission has received a barrage of hostile letters, too, some foreshadowing legal action. In March, the Futures Industry Association urged the commission to scrap its plan for reining in speculative commodities trading, saying it may be legally infirm.
Bart Chilton, a Democratic commissioner at the agency who has championed tough position limits on oil, corn and the like, sought feedback on the plan from the CME Group, the nation’s largest futures exchange. But at CME’s Chicago headquarters last fall, executives declined to discuss the proposal with Mr. Chilton, saying the Commodity Futures Trading Commission lacked the legal authority to impose trading limits.
With the industry firing such warning shots, regulators have spent months shielding their rules from litigation.
In May, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s general counsel and chief economist issued a memo spelling out guidelines for cost-benefit analyses. The memo and other efforts to slow down the Dodd-Frank rules later drew rare praise from the agency’s internal watchdog, which said the commission has taken proactive steps to address concerns.
Scott O’Malia, a Republican commissioner at the futures trading commission, also called for the agency to re-examine every cost-benefit analysis drawn up for Dodd-Frank. Mr. O’Malia warned this month that the commission does not have the final word, as the S.E.C. has recently learned.
Still, most regulators are hesitant to strike the panic button.
Mr. Chilton said that theyhear about potential lawsuits with some frequency, and there’s an old saying in Washington that, if you’re not part of the solution, there’s plenty of money to be made being part of the problem.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Summary Box: Feds close FDA Whistleblower Probe

Associated Press

CASE CLOSED AGAIN: For the second time this year, federal inspectors have dismissed allegations by Food and Drug Administration scientists who say they were pressured into approving medical devices.

WHISTLEBLOWERS: FDA medical device reviewers allege that agency managers improperly overruled their opinions and tried to intimidate them when they went public with their concerns.

WIDER SCOPE: Federal inspectors previously dismissed the whistleblower complaints in February, but agreed to reopen the case after lawmakers and outside groups complained about the limited scope of the investigation.