Original Story: wkms.org
The energy that lights up, turns on, cools and heats our lives leaves a trail of waste. Natural gas is no exception. The waste from the gas drilling known as “fracking” is often radioactive. The gas industry produces thousands of tons of this “hot” waste and companies and state regulators throughout the Ohio River valley and Marcellus Shale gas region struggle to find safe ways to get rid of it. One option to consider is chemical holding tanks.
Last August a convoy of trucks carrying a concentrated form of this waste traveled from northern West Virginia to Irvine, Kentucky. The small town in Estill County lies near the Kentucky River, where Appalachian hills give way to rolling farm country.
The trucks were headed for a municipal waste facility called Blue Ridge Landfill. Just across Highway 89 from the landfill is the home where Denny and Vivian Smith live on property where their ancestors have lived since the 1800s. This may need a Tulsa Environmental Lawyer to sort things out.
“This is our home place,” Vivian Smith said from her sun porch. “This is roots for us.”
From their sun porch, facing east, the Smiths can see the entrance to Blue Ridge Landfill. From their front door, facing west, they can see Estill County High School and Estill County Middle School, with a combined enrollment of about 1,200 students.
The trucks that arrived in Irvine last summer left more than 400 tons of low-level radioactive waste in a facility that was not engineered or permitted to accept that sort of material. That has left the community, the parents of schoolchildren, and especially the Smiths with a lot of questions and concerns. -- “We are getting older and we feel like we’re kind of vulnerable to illnesses with what’s going on at the landfill,” Vivian Smith said. A South Jersey Environmental Lawyer is watching the case closely.
The question now reverberating through Irvine and the state agencies investigating the incident: How did this happen?
The answer, in part, lies in the weak federal oversight and patchwork of state regulations regarding this type of waste.
A report from the Center for Public Integrity calls the radioactive waste stream from horizontal oil and gas operations “orphan waste” because no single government agency is fully managing it. Each state is left to figure out its own plan. Ohio, for example, hasn’t formalized waste rules, while New York, which banned fracking, still allows waste disposal “with little oversight,” according to the Center.
Antero Resources petroleum engineer Tom Waltz points to eight, green, 16,000-gallon above-ground storage tanks at the edge of a drilling pad in Doddridge County, West Virginia.
“They hold produced water that the producing wells make,” he explained.
Produced water is one form of drilling waste. It’s salty water laced with chemicals, metals, and naturally occurring radioactive elements that come up thousands of feet along with the gas and oil. Antero is the country’s eighth-largest gas drilling company and operates hundreds of sites like this, producing hundreds of thousands of barrels of waste.
The easiest way to get rid of wastewater is to inject it back into the ground, but that can lead to pollution and even earthquakes. One of Antero’s lead civil engineers, Conrad Baston, says processing the wastewater – separating it into salt, sludge, and water – is becoming more attractive.
No Easy Solutions
Antero is spending $275 million to construct a wastewater facility in West Virginia which is scheduled to begin operation in September, 2017. At its peak, the facility could see up to 600 trucks a day, processing 60,000 barrels of wastewater.
A filtering system would recover about two-thirds of the water, which could be reused in drilling. But that filtration system leaves behind thousands of tons of salt and hundreds of tons of sludge from the sediment, which concentrates the radioactive materials. Baston said that sludge — as much as 180 tons a day — will be disposed of elsewhere.
“Given some of the flux in the regulatory environment with regard to those sludges,” he said, “we’ve elected to take those sludges to a landfill that’s currently licensed to accept it.”
Baston couldn’t say which facilities or where, but he said Antero is exploring options across the country. West Virginia’s Department of Environmental Protection said no approved facilities exist in the state. That would mean the waste will have to cross state lines. An Antero spokesperson said waste from their facility will go only to approved and vetted landfills.
The Center for Public Integrity report shows that regulators acknowledge that this waste is effectively being “shopped around” by companies hoping for affordable disposal. Antero officials maintain that industry has no other choice. A Denver Environmental Litigation Lawyer says this step is critical.
Records filed with the West Virginia Bureau for Public Health show that a company Antero had contracted with to process its wastewater, Fairmont Brine, was the source of the waste that wound up in Blue Ridge Landfill in Irvine, Kentucky. Antero officials said their company is not responsible for how that waste was disposed of. Officials at Fairmont Brine did not respond to requests to comment for this story.
Waiting for Answers
Since reporters at the Louisville Courier-Journal first reported on the improper dumping of fracking waste in Kentucky, community leaders in Irvine have been asking for answers. The landfill is under investigation by multiple state agencies for accepting the waste.
“Knowing that there was nothing going on to protect us,” Vivian Smith said, “I think it’s like the henhouse was not guarded and the fox got in.”
The Smiths have had their share of illnesses and they wonder what effect the radioactive waste might have on them or on the children who attend school nearby. This low-level radioactive waste is not as hazardous as the wastes from nuclear power. But according the the Environmental Protection Agency, the radioactive materials in drilling waste do present risks. Radioactive dust is potentially harmful and it would be bad if the radioactive leachate, or liquid that oozes out from the landfill, were to contaminate groundwater over time. Radioactive waste can last centuries — far longer than the engineered lifespan of the liners in many landfills. A San Antonio Environmental Lawyer may need to be contacted.
Officials with Blue Ridge Landfill’s parent company, Advanced Disposal, declined to comment while under investigation. The Smiths hope that investigation will shed light on any risks they might be living with because of the hot mess left next door.
Showing posts with label environmental lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label environmental lawyer. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 22, 2016
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Ecuador Seeks Damages from Chevron for Oil Spill
Chevron Corp. (CVX) is facing its first test of whether farmers and fishermen from the Amazon rainforest will collect $19 billion in environmental damages from the world’s fourth-largest oil company.
A group of 47 Ecuadoreans have asked Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice to seize Chevron assets in Canada, ranging from an oil sands project to offshore wells, to satisfy a 2011 court ruling in the Latin American nation that ordered the company to pay for oil pollution dating to the 1960s. Chevron said the Ecuadorean judgment is outside Ontario’s jurisdiction and that the ruling resulted from bribery and fraud.
A hearing in Toronto today marks the Ecuadoreans’ inaugural step in a global collection effort that includes seizure attempts in Argentina and Brazil. The Ecuadoreans estimated Chevron has $12 billion in Canadian assets, a figure that equates to almost half of the company’s 2011 profit. An adverse Ontario ruling for Chevron would put at risk fuel-manufacturing and oil-production operations across Canada.
Robert Sweet, who helps manage $150 million at Horizon Investment Services in Hammond, Indiana, said it is a cause for concern, and as with all ecological disasters will take a long time to resolve.
The company’s presence in Canada dates back to the 1930s and includes an oil-refining complex in British Columbia, an Alberta oil-sands venture, offshore wells in the Atlantic Ocean, and cash held in Canadian bank accounts.
Every Strategy
San Ramon, California-based Chevron was on the losing side of last year’s ruling by a provincial Ecuadorean court that blamed decades of toxic soil and water contamination on Texaco Inc., which Chevron acquired in 2001. Texaco was found to have discharged into the environment saltwater and other byproducts of oil drilling. Texaco quit the country and its equipment was taken over by the Ecuadorean state oil company in 1992.The $19 billion ruling handed down last year by a court in Lago Agrio, a town near Ecuador’s border with Colombia, held Chevron accountable for health and environmental damages resulting from chemical-laden wastewater dumped from 1964 to 1992.
The Ecuadorean plaintiffs, from the remote northern Amazon River basin, are seeking enforcement of the judgment outside their home country because Chevron has no refineries, oil wells, storage terminals or other properties in the nation. Pablo Fajardo, their lead lawyer in Ecuador, said during a February 2011 conference call with reporters he would use every strategy and manner at his disposal to collect the award.
Corporate Veil
In a Nov. 23 filing, Chevron argued the Ontario court has no jurisdiction to grant the Ecuadorean judgment because the company’s Canadian units are indirect subsidiaries with independent boards separated from the U.S. parent by several levels of ownership.The Ecuadoreans face an “uphill battle” because they must convince the court that Chevron and its Canadian operations should be treated as one entity rather than separate companies, said Barry Leon, a partner and head of the international arbitration group at Perley-Robertson, Hill & McDougall LLP in Ottawa.
Chevron rose 0.8 percent to $106.35 at 9:35 a.m. in New York today. The shares have increased 9.1 percent in the past year.
Pending Arbitration
According to Chevron Chairman and Chief Executive Officer John Watson, the Ecuadoreans’ lawyers have blackmailed judges, bribed judges, falsified evidence, falsified expert witnesses, ghostwritten expert opinions and ghostwritten court judgments. If the plaintiffs were confident in the “integrity” of the ruling, they would seek enforcement in U.S. courts with jurisdiction over the parent company, Kent Robertson, a company spokesman, said in an e-mailed statement.Alan Lenczner, the Toronto attorney from the firm Lenczner Slaght Royce Smith Griffin LP representing the Ecuadoreans, when reached by phone declined to comment on the case.
Leon said it is likely that the initial decisions will be appealed.
Chevron doesn’t disclose how much it spends on legal fees.
The Hague
Chevron is awaiting a ruling in a related case before the Permanent Court of Arbitration, the 113-year-old panel based in The Hague that handles trade disputes between corporations and nations. Chevron filed the arbitration claim in 2009, accusing the government of Ecuador of reneging on a 1998 contract that absolved Texaco of Amazonian pollution claims. Three days of hearings in the case concluded yesterday, Robertson said.Chevron’s campaign to avoid payment suffered a setback last month when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a lower-court decision that rejected the company’s request for a pre-emptive block on collection efforts in Chevron’s home country. The lower court had ruled that it didn’t have authority to thwart payment when the Ecuadoreans hadn’t yet filed such a claim in the U.S.
Unfair Influence
Following the filing of their Canadian seizure request in May, the Ecuadoreans sought similar forfeitures in a Brazilian tribunal in June and in Argentina earlier this month. A judge in Buenos Aires ordered some Chevron bank deposits held in escrow while the case is pending, Enrique Bruchou, a lawyer for the Ecuadoreans, said in an interview on Nov. 7.Today, in paid statements published in two Argentine newspapers, Chevron urged the local court to release its money from escrow and indicated the company intends to pursue a legal defense identical to that employed in Canada. “Chevron Argentina has never had operations in Ecuador and has no relation with the fraudulent trial in Ecuador,” the company said in the newspapers Clarin and La Nacion.
Transparency International
Chevron has accused the Ecuadorean government of unfairly influencing court proceedings that led to the $19 billion ruling and alleged that a damage assessment provided by a court- appointed expert was ghostwritten by consultants and lawyers hired by the plaintiffs.Lawyers for the Ecuadoreans including Stephen Donzinger have accused Chevron of engaging in a campaign to discredit them, entrap an Ecuadorean judge that presided over the case and set up dummy corporations in Ecuador to hide Chevron’s alleged role in testing soil samples from the pollution sites.
Ecuador ranked 120th out of 183 nations in Transparency International’s 2011 corruption-perception index, where No. 1 New Zealand is perceived to be the most honest. Albania, Liberia and Lesotho were perceived as less corrupt than Ecuador, according to the index.
US gulf coast officials have yet to comment, while companies like Sarasota Condo Rentals continue their best efforts at business since the 2010 spill.
In February 2011, Chevron filed a racketeering lawsuit that’s ongoing against the Ecuadoreans and their lawyers in New York for “leading a fraudulent litigation and PR campaign against the company.”
Exxon Mobil Corp. (XOM) is the world’s biggest oil company by market value, followed by PetroChina Company Ltd. and Royal Dutch Shell Plc (RDSA), according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Property Owners Fighting Eminent Domain
First appeared in Associated Press
When federal regulators approved a 39-mile natural gas
pipeline through northern Pennsylvania's pristine Endless Mountains, they cited
the operator's assurances that it would make sparing use of eminent domain as
it negotiated with more than 150 property owners along the pipeline's route.
Yet a few days after winning approval for its $250 million
MARC 1 pipeline in the heart of the giant Marcellus Shale gas field, the
company began condemnation proceedings against nearly half of the landowners -
undercutting part of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's approval rationale
and angering landowners.
Some of the landowners are now fighting the company in
court, complaining that Central New York Oil and Gas Company LLC steamrolled
them by refusing to negotiate in good faith on monetary compensation and the
pipeline's location. Their attorneys say CNYOG has skirted Pennsylvania's
eminent domain rules.
The company, a subsidiary of Inergy LP of Kansas City, Mo.,
insists it's trying to reach a "fair settlement" with all property
owners and wants to be a good neighbor.
The dispute could foreshadow eminent domain battles to come
as more pipelines are approved and built to carry shale gas to market in states
like Pennsylvania, New York and Ohio.
The company promotes the MARC 1 pipeline as key
infrastructure in developing the Marcellus Shale, a rock formation underneath
Pennsylvania and surrounding states that experts believe holds the nation's
largest reservoir of gas. The MARC 1, a high-pressure steel pipeline 30 inches
in diameter, will connect to major interstate pipelines and the company's own
natural gas storage facility in southern New York state.
CNYOG hopes to start construction soon and finish by July,
but it awaits permits from Pennsylvania environmental regulators and the U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers.
It also needs to answer the legal challenge from residents.
Many of the complaining landowners say they favor natural
gas drilling and some have leased land to gas drillers. What rankles them is
that FERC has invested CNYOG with the power of eminent domain, taking away
their bargaining power.
"Once the government becomes involved, this is what
happens. Because you lose that leverage," said a landowner who faces
condemnation of part of their 175-acre parcel in Sullivan County.
The landowners say CNYOG offered less than a third of the
amount that another pipeline company had previously paid them to install a
gathering line on their land. The difference? Gathering lines - smaller
pipelines that take gas from the wellhead to a transmission line or processing
facility - are not regulated by the federal government and companies that
operate them don't have condemnation power.
A landowner said a company representative who made them the
lowball offer told them to "take it or leave it."
"There's no negotiating with this company. They come
and they tell you what they're going to do. They're telling you what they're
going to pay. And they're counting on the government to enforce it," said
a landowner in a recent interview at the Sullivan County Courthouse, where a
judge has scheduled a mid-February hearing on the landowners' concerns.
Amounts offered by CNYOG range from a few hundred dollars to
tens of thousands of dollars, depending on the amount of property taken. Court
papers filed by CNYOG in late December say it valued damages at 37 condemned
properties in Sullivan County at $310,900.
The pipeline has been controversial since it was first proposed
two years ago.
FERC, which considers all applications for new interstate
pipelines, received 22,000 comments on the MARC 1 project, with many expressing
concern about environmental and safety impacts. The Environmental Protection
Agency also worried about potential damage to the forest ecosystem, noting the
pipeline will cross dozens of pristine waterways in an area popular with
hikers, hunters and fishermen.
FERC ultimately determined the pipeline would not
significantly impact the environment and allowed it to proceed.
The commission was also supposed to consider whether there
would be an "unneeded exercise" of eminent domain - the
often-contentious legal process by which the government, or a party such as a
public utility, takes private property for public benefit.
Indeed, the commission said last year its approval relied on
the company's assertion that it was acquiring land "through negotiated
agreements with landowners, thus minimizing the need" to condemn people's
land.
In reality, the company had prepared condemnation papers for
dozens of properties even before winning commission approval on Nov. 14. Within
a few days, it began eminent domain proceedings against 74 of 152 property
owners along the pipeline's route through the mountains of Bradford, Lycoming
and Sullivan counties.
An attorney for the environmental group Earthjustice, said
the large number of condemnations suggests that CNYOG "never made a
serious effort to get negotiated agreements with the landowners that the
landowners thought were fair." Earthjustice has intervened in the case and
is challenging the pipeline's approval.
While most of the landowners receiving condemnation papers
have since settled - the company says private agreement has been reached with
more than 80 percent of the landowners – an environmental lawyer suggested the
pace of settlements has quickened because condemnation takes leverage away from
the property owner.
The company insists it has met its obligation to negotiate.
Its attorney said there were several "meet-in-the-middle cases"
involving compromise.
"It's not like we were sitting silently until the FERC
order and rushed to the courthouse," said the company’s attorney who is
based in Vestal, N.Y. "To say we did not attempt to negotiate in good
faith is incorrect."
The lawyer acknowledged, however, that CNYOG told landowners
that if they challenged the company in court, forcing it to incur legal
expenses, then any deal on the table would be withdrawn.
Some landowners aren't interested in the money. They're more
concerned about the pipeline's route.
CNYOG told a landowner that it plans to cut a 50-foot-wide,
400-foot-long gash through an ancient stand of trees across the front of his
property. When the landowner proposed an alternate route through an open field
that would preserve his trees and views, the company said it wasn't interested
and offered instead to pay him for the wood.
"That's not negotiation. It was their way or no way,
and 'we'll see you in court.' It's the little guys against Goliath," said the
landowner, who has challenged the company in court.
Another landowner has appealed to federal regulators to
force CNYOG to abandon plans for an access road along her property. She said
the road is at the bottom of a long hill and around a sharp bend where there
have been many accidents, at least one of them fatal.
When the landownder pressed the company to use an alternate
route a short distance away, she said, the company told her that would result
in a six-month delay.
"I want them to go elsewhere. I don't want somebody to
die because of stupidity," she said.
In a statement, the company said it has accommodated dozens
of landowner requests for route changes, but can't do more because of
"environmental, cultural and biological restrictions as well as other land
use constraints."
Some landowners who didn't bother fighting the pipeline say
the company still managed to leave a bad taste.
A landowner in Sonestown said she signed with CNYOG because
she didn't feel it was worth it to hire a lawyer to fight for more money. Even
as she signed the paperwork, she got a hint of the company's negotiating
stance.
"They said that other people were holding out because
they wanted more money," the landowner recalled. "They said, 'We're
not paying more money because this is a federal line that's going to go through
no matter what, and $2 a foot is what we pay.'"
Friday, January 27, 2012
Chevron Facing Criminal Charges in Brazil
First USA Today
Reuters is reporting that a November oil spill off Brazil
will likely result in criminal charges "within weeks" against Chevron
Corp., its top local executive and some employees of Transocean Ltd., the
drilling rig firm involved in the Gulf of Mexico disaster. A West
Hollywood Environmental Lawyer watched closely.
Three Brazilian government officials involved in the case
told Reuters that a federal court filing "will likely include a request
for criminal indictment" of George Buck, chief executive of Chevron's
Brazil unit, along with other staff members.
The case has not yet been presented to a judge, who would
decide "whether to accept the charges and proceed with indictments,"
Reuters writes.
Chevron spokesman Kurt Glaubitz told Reuters the
California-based oil giant "believes that the charges are without
merit" and that "Chevron is confident that once all the facts are
fully examined, they will demonstrate that Chevron responded appropriately and
responsibly to the incident."
A Transocean spokesman declined to comment. A Portland
Environmental Lawyer was interested in the non-comment.
Federal prosecutors have already filed a civil lawsuit that
seeks $11 billion for the 2,400-barrel spill about 75 miles off the
southeastern coast of Brazil.
A Federal Police report has accused Chevron and Transocean
of taking "unacceptable" risks and concluded that the 4,000-foot-deep
well "could not and should not have been drilled." Police recommended
that 17 individuals be indicted, including as many as 12 from Chevron, Reuters
says, citing legal documents
A pressure "kick" from natural gas occurred Nov. 7
after the well was tapped in the Fade oil field, triggering an emergency
blowout preventer. But days later, oil was found leaking from the ocean floor
several hundred feet from the plugged well.
The failure of a blowout preventer triggered the April 2010
explosion and fire that destroyed a Transocean rig drilling for BP and resulted
in the historic Gulf disaster. No criminal charges were ever filed. Although, a
Salt
Lake City Environmental Lawyer was curious about the situation.
Today in New Orleans, a federal judge ruled that
Transocean's contract with BP shielded it from paying many pollution claims but
that the rig owner is not exempt from punitive damages and civil penalties.
In his ruling, U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier said
Transocean is responsible for claims directly related to pollution caused by
its Deepwater Horizon rig.
Labels:
Brazil,
Chevron Corp,
environmental lawyer,
Environmentalism
Transocean Saved by BP Contract
First appeared in USA Today
The rig owner involved in drilling the ill-fated well that
blew out in the Gulf of Mexico and spewed more than 200 million gallons of oil
will not have to pay many pollution claims because it was shielded in a
contract with well-owner BP, a federal judge ruled Thursday. A Wash DC Environmental Lawyer watches.
The ruling comes as BP, the U.S. southern states affected by
the disaster and the federal government are discussing a settlement over America's
largest offshore oil spill.
BP PLC, Transocean Ltd. and Halliburton Co. have been
sparring over who was at fault for causing the blowout. The out-of-control well
was capped in July 2010. Federal investigators have said that BP bears ultimate
responsibility for the spill, but has faulted all three companies to some
degree. An Amsterdam
Environmental Lawyer watches the case closely.
Thursday's decision may have spared Transocean from having
to pay potentially billions of dollars in damage claims. However, U.S. District
Judge Carl Barbier said the driller still is not exempt from paying punitive
damages and civil penalties that arise from the April 20, 2010, blowout 100
miles off the Louisiana coast. Those penalties could amount to billions of
dollars.
Law experts were split over who is a clear-cut winner. A New Orleans Environmental Lawyer is pretty decided.
BP has been pursuing agreements with multiple parties to
reach settlements that would make an upcoming trial involving hundreds of spill
lawsuits in New Orleans unnecessary, or at least resolve as many of the issues
as possible.
The Justice Department also is involved, working with the
states to create an outline for a settlement that would resolve their
potentially multibillion dollar claims against BP and the other companies
involved in the disaster, Alabama Attorney General Luther Strange told The
Associated Press.
Justice led a meeting last week in Washington among the U.S.
states in an effort to formulate an agreement that would satisfy government and
state claims, including penalties and fines, Strange said. He also indicated if
there is a settlement that officials are discussing what to do with the $20
billion fund set up by BP to pay victims. A Chicago
Environmental Lawyer hopes there’s more to come.
The lead attorneys for individuals and businesses suing BP
were not at the meeting.
According to Strange, a federal magistrate judge has been
asked to expedite settlement discussions. The Louisiana attorney general's
office said in a statement to the AP that it is in settlement discussions with
BP, which would not comment on any deals in the works. A first phase of the
trial is set for Feb. 27 to determine liability for the spill.
"The closer you get to a trial date, the more pressure
builds to reach a settlement," Strange said.
Despite the decision, BP claimed victory and said Barbier's
ruling "at a minimum" left Transocean facing "punitive damages,
fines and penalties flowing from its own conduct." A St.
Louis Environmental Lawyer is wondering what’s next.
Transocean spokesman Lou Colasuonno said in an emailed
statement that the company was pleased to see its position affirmed.
"This confirms that BP is responsible for all economic
damages caused by the oil that leaked from its Macondo well, and discredits
BP's ongoing attempts to evade both its contractual and financial
obligations," he said.
Blaine LeCesne, an associate professor at Loyola University
law school, however, said Barbier's ruling was a "major victory" for
Transocean.
"If anything is going to compel the parties toward
settlement, it's going to be this," he said. "I think BP is in a very
bad position now, and they don't have a lot of leverage."
A University of Michigan Law School professor who served as
chief of the Justice Department's environmental crimes section said the ruling
had no clear-cut winner. David Uhlmann said it prevents BP from collecting
billions of dollars from Transocean to help cover cleanup costs and pay for
claims over economic losses and environmental damage from the spill. But the
decision leaves Transocean facing potentially billions of dollars in civil and
criminal penalties under the Clean Water Act, he added. A Fresno
Environmental Lawyer may agree.
"It's a partial win for each side and a partial loss
for each side," Uhlmann said.
Under a drilling contract, BP and Transocean agreed to
indemnify each other in the case of an accident, with BP taking responsibility
for pollution originating from the well and Transocean for any pollution or
accidents aboard the rig.
However, in court BP argued that the contract did not shield
Transocean if the drilling company acted in manner that was grossly negligent.
Barbier said the contract was a "clear and unequivocal
agreement" to provide "broad indemnity."
"As we have said from the beginning, Transocean cannot
avoid its responsibility for this accident," BP said.
The British oil giant said it had "stepped up" and
admitted its role in the spill and paid billions of dollars in claims.
BP also is eager to resolve its disputes with its partners
on the doomed rig. The companies have sued and countersued each other for
billions of dollars to protect themselves when it comes to paying damages to
victims and penalties to the government.
Months ago, BP offered to resolve its dispute with
Transocean if Transocean paid BP roughly $4.5 billion, according to a person
briefed on the discussions who spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity
because the talks are confidential. Transocean rejected the offer, and there
have been no substantive discussions between the companies about figures since
then, the person said, adding that Thursday's ruling could spur further talks.
A Pittsburgh
Environmental Lawyer is curious.
Eric Schaeffer, who led the Environmental Protection
Agency's civil enforcement office from 1997 to 2002, said Thursday's ruling
will put even more pressure on BP.
"If BP is less able to shift some of those costs to
Transocean, if they understand they are going to bear Transocean's share of
compensatory damages, I'd want to get it settled," Schaeffer said.
"That's no longer a wild card."
Labels:
BP Oil,
BP Transocean,
environmental lawyer,
Environmentalism,
Oil Spill
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)