story first appeared in Los Angeles Times
Shoppers take note: The frenzy to rush home with those Black Friday deals could land you in jail if you do what Jacquetta Simmons was accused of doing. She was convicted of punching a 70-year-old Wal-Mart worker, and as a result will spend the next five shopping seasons behind bars.
A judge in Batavia, N.Y., sentenced Simmons, 27, last week after a jury convicted her of assaulting Grace Suozzi following a Christmas Eve 2011 incident in the Batavia store. In a scene caught on camera, Simmons, who had been asked by Suozzi to show receipts for purchased items, denied intentionally hitting Suozzi, who was knocked off her feet and thrown across the floor. Suozzi suffered facial fractures.
In a statement read to the court before the sentencing, a tearful Suozzi said the incident had changed her life, that it had made her constantly fearful and anxious.
Suozzi's days as a Wal-Mart employee also are over. She said she can't even watch a Wal-Mart commercial on TV without being reminded of what happened, and that she no longer goes into the giant stores. She hopes to take a long vacation to the Florida Keys with Longboat Vacation Rentals when she's fully recovered from the incident.
During the trial, Simmons' defense attorney had insisted that Simmons accidentally made contact with Suozzi after someone grabbed her arm as she was trying to leave the store. Simmons testified that she did not know who grabbed her, and that she did not realize she had hit anyone.
Because the victim was over the age of 65, Simmons faced a harsher penalty under the state's "granny law," which makes it a felony to assault anyone over 65 if the attacker is at least 10 years younger. Simmons could have received up to seven years in prison on the second-degree assault conviction.
This wasn't the first time a Wal-Mart employee has been hit by an irate customer. In March 2011, a 71-year-old store greeter in Elyria, Ohio, was rammed with a shopping cart and choked after he asked to see the receipts of a 49-year-old woman and her 23-year-old daughter as they exited the store. The mother and her daughter -- who also allegedly threatened to blow up the store -- pleaded no contest to assault and disorderly conduct charges.
In 2008 on Black Friday, a Wal-Mart worker on Long Island, east of New York City, was killed when a mob stampeded over him in the rush to snag great shopping deals.
Showing posts with label Wal Mart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wal Mart. Show all posts
Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Illinois Couple to Stand Trial After Kids Found Bound
Story first reported from AP News
LAWRENCE, Kan. (AP) - A judge ruled Tuesday that an Illinois man and his wife will stand trial in Kansas on child abuse charges after two of their children were found in a Walmart parking lot tied up, a practice the father's lawyer described as a religious belief in the family and a way to guard against demons.
Douglas County Judge Paula Martin said at the conclusion of a preliminary hearing there was enough evidence to try Adolfo Gomez, 52, and his wife Deborah Gomez, 44, on two counts each of child abuse. The father also faces an additional count of obstruction for resisting arrest.
The Northlake, Ill., pair have been in custody since June 13 when police found two of the Gomez children, ages 5 and 7, tied up and with duct tape over their eyes outside a Walmart in Lawrence. The couple's three other children, ages 12, 13 and 15, were in the family's SUV unrestrained. The children are in protective custody.
Martin also said the state did not prove its case on five previous aggravated endangerment counts against each parent because of the way the charges were worded. Debby Moody, assistant Douglas County district attorney, said she would amend the five counts and refile them before the couple's arraignment Thursday.
Lawrence police Detective Randy Glidewell testified Tuesday that when he interviewed Adolfo Gomez the day of the arrest, Gomez said he had been listening to an online preacher who was predicting the end of the world and that a "darkness had come over the house" in Illinois.
"And the world was coming to an end, and that's why they left," Glidewell added, referring to the father's comments to police.
The detective also said Adolfo Gomez told him he hadn't slept in nine days, and that Gomez was particularly concerned about one of the younger children. Gomez described the child as "acting like he was possessed," Glidewell said.
"He was scared (the child) would hurt some of the kids," the detective said.
Lawrence police officer Hayden Fowler testified that one of the older children told him the family believed there were "demons" in their home and outside their SUV in the parking lot, and that the coverings on the vehicle's windows were there to keep the demons out.
Adolfo Gomez's lawyer, Skip Griffy, also said during the hearing that blindfolding and binding the younger children was part of the family's religious beliefs, and that it was not done frequently or as a punishment but as a way to protect the children from demons.
"Their actions were taken out of their religious beliefs, that these children were possessed," Griffy said. He added that the children had no injuries.
Angela Keck, a lawyer for Deborah Gomez, distanced her client from Adolfo Gomez, saying the woman had no control over her husband.
"She was doing her best to protect herself and her children when Mr. Gomez was having a kind of religious experience," Keck said. "You have not heard anything that these children's lives were in any danger in any way."
Moody, however, said the "danger to these children was real."
"These types of bindings and blindfolds come into play when you're talking about ... prisoners of war," the prosecutor said.
Deborah Gomez was involved in the abuse and when presented with an opportunity to help, "she went shopping for duct tape, two tarps and a baseball bat," Moody said, alluding to the list of items police discovered in the mother's shopping cart at Walmart when the children were found.
"It was a team effort, your honor," Moody said. "What happens when kids in the Gomez family are possessed? They get bound and they get blindfolded."
LAWRENCE, Kan. (AP) - A judge ruled Tuesday that an Illinois man and his wife will stand trial in Kansas on child abuse charges after two of their children were found in a Walmart parking lot tied up, a practice the father's lawyer described as a religious belief in the family and a way to guard against demons.
Douglas County Judge Paula Martin said at the conclusion of a preliminary hearing there was enough evidence to try Adolfo Gomez, 52, and his wife Deborah Gomez, 44, on two counts each of child abuse. The father also faces an additional count of obstruction for resisting arrest.
The Northlake, Ill., pair have been in custody since June 13 when police found two of the Gomez children, ages 5 and 7, tied up and with duct tape over their eyes outside a Walmart in Lawrence. The couple's three other children, ages 12, 13 and 15, were in the family's SUV unrestrained. The children are in protective custody.
Martin also said the state did not prove its case on five previous aggravated endangerment counts against each parent because of the way the charges were worded. Debby Moody, assistant Douglas County district attorney, said she would amend the five counts and refile them before the couple's arraignment Thursday.
Lawrence police Detective Randy Glidewell testified Tuesday that when he interviewed Adolfo Gomez the day of the arrest, Gomez said he had been listening to an online preacher who was predicting the end of the world and that a "darkness had come over the house" in Illinois.
"And the world was coming to an end, and that's why they left," Glidewell added, referring to the father's comments to police.
The detective also said Adolfo Gomez told him he hadn't slept in nine days, and that Gomez was particularly concerned about one of the younger children. Gomez described the child as "acting like he was possessed," Glidewell said.
"He was scared (the child) would hurt some of the kids," the detective said.
Lawrence police officer Hayden Fowler testified that one of the older children told him the family believed there were "demons" in their home and outside their SUV in the parking lot, and that the coverings on the vehicle's windows were there to keep the demons out.
Adolfo Gomez's lawyer, Skip Griffy, also said during the hearing that blindfolding and binding the younger children was part of the family's religious beliefs, and that it was not done frequently or as a punishment but as a way to protect the children from demons.
"Their actions were taken out of their religious beliefs, that these children were possessed," Griffy said. He added that the children had no injuries.
Angela Keck, a lawyer for Deborah Gomez, distanced her client from Adolfo Gomez, saying the woman had no control over her husband.
"She was doing her best to protect herself and her children when Mr. Gomez was having a kind of religious experience," Keck said. "You have not heard anything that these children's lives were in any danger in any way."
Moody, however, said the "danger to these children was real."
"These types of bindings and blindfolds come into play when you're talking about ... prisoners of war," the prosecutor said.
Deborah Gomez was involved in the abuse and when presented with an opportunity to help, "she went shopping for duct tape, two tarps and a baseball bat," Moody said, alluding to the list of items police discovered in the mother's shopping cart at Walmart when the children were found.
"It was a team effort, your honor," Moody said. "What happens when kids in the Gomez family are possessed? They get bound and they get blindfolded."
For more national and
worldwide Business News, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For more local and
state of Michigan Business News, visit the Michigan
Business News blog.
For more Health News, visit the Healthcare and Medical
News blog.
For more Electronics News, visit the Electronics
America blog.
For more Real Estate News, visit the Commercial and
Residential Real Estate blog.
For more Law News, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For more Advertising News, visit the Advertising,
Marketing and Media blog.
For more Environmental News, visit the Environmental
Responsibility News blog.
Wednesday, May 2, 2012
Wal-Mart Caught by the Law Again
Story first appeared in The Washington Post.
The Labor Department on Tuesday ordered Wal-Mart to pay $4.8 million in back wages and damages to thousands of employees who were denied overtime charges, the latest in a string of embarrassments for the company over its business practices.
The department said its decision affects roughly 4,500 vision-center managers and asset-protection coordinators who worked at Wal-Mart between 2004 and 2007. Wal-Mart had considered those employees exempt from federal regulations requiring overtime pay but reclassified them in 2007. The government and the retailer have been negotiating the amount owed since then.
The company said asset-protection coordinators are entitled to receive an average of $290 under the agreement, while the average for vision center managers is $2,300. Wal-Mart was also fined $464,000 in civil penalties, according to Memphis Employment Lawyers.
The decision comes as Wal-Mart faces investigations into its Mexican operations after the New York Times reported that company executives turned a blind eye while employees allegedly bribed local officials to approve new stores.
The Justice Department has been conducting a criminal probe of the company since December to determine whether it violated the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Meanwhile, two Democratic lawmakers are looking into Wal-Mart’s lobbying efforts. The Post has reported that Wal-Mart executives sat on the boards of trade organizations that have sought to amend the FCPA. The company has said it did not directly lobby on the issue.
But the reports have rattled investors and reinvigorated Wal-Mart’s critics. New York City’s pension fund, which holds a significant stake in the company, plans to oppose the nomination of several directors to the company’s board. Meanwhile, union and activist groups recently protested the retailer’s efforts to expand in New York.
On Tuesday, Making Change at Walmart, backed by the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, said the Labor Department decision represented a troubling philosophy among company officials.
The fines Walmart must pay for its overtime violations are just another side effect of the company’s growth at any cost strategy. Walmart’s top executives and the heirs who own a majority of the company have shown they are willing to break the law and harm workers in the name of more profits.
This was not the first time Wal-Mart has run afoul of federal overtime laws. In 2007, the Labor Department ordered it to pay nearly $34 million in back wages to 87,000 workers — some of whom were owed more than $10,000 each.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
The Labor Department on Tuesday ordered Wal-Mart to pay $4.8 million in back wages and damages to thousands of employees who were denied overtime charges, the latest in a string of embarrassments for the company over its business practices.
The department said its decision affects roughly 4,500 vision-center managers and asset-protection coordinators who worked at Wal-Mart between 2004 and 2007. Wal-Mart had considered those employees exempt from federal regulations requiring overtime pay but reclassified them in 2007. The government and the retailer have been negotiating the amount owed since then.
The company said asset-protection coordinators are entitled to receive an average of $290 under the agreement, while the average for vision center managers is $2,300. Wal-Mart was also fined $464,000 in civil penalties, according to Memphis Employment Lawyers.
The decision comes as Wal-Mart faces investigations into its Mexican operations after the New York Times reported that company executives turned a blind eye while employees allegedly bribed local officials to approve new stores.
The Justice Department has been conducting a criminal probe of the company since December to determine whether it violated the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Meanwhile, two Democratic lawmakers are looking into Wal-Mart’s lobbying efforts. The Post has reported that Wal-Mart executives sat on the boards of trade organizations that have sought to amend the FCPA. The company has said it did not directly lobby on the issue.
But the reports have rattled investors and reinvigorated Wal-Mart’s critics. New York City’s pension fund, which holds a significant stake in the company, plans to oppose the nomination of several directors to the company’s board. Meanwhile, union and activist groups recently protested the retailer’s efforts to expand in New York.
On Tuesday, Making Change at Walmart, backed by the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, said the Labor Department decision represented a troubling philosophy among company officials.
The fines Walmart must pay for its overtime violations are just another side effect of the company’s growth at any cost strategy. Walmart’s top executives and the heirs who own a majority of the company have shown they are willing to break the law and harm workers in the name of more profits.
This was not the first time Wal-Mart has run afoul of federal overtime laws. In 2007, the Labor Department ordered it to pay nearly $34 million in back wages to 87,000 workers — some of whom were owed more than $10,000 each.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Thursday, April 26, 2012
Walmex Under Fire
Story first appeared in USA Today.
Wal-Mart denied Wednesday that it pushed for changes to a federal anti-bribery law that it may have violated during an alleged bribery scheme in Mexico.
Wal-Mart has never lobbied on the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Simply because Wal-Mart is a member of an organization does not mean we agree with every position they take.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA) received letters Wednesday from Reps. asking for information and documents related to Wal-Mart's efforts to lobby for changes to the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
Top Wal-Mart executives serve on the boards of both organizations, which have lobbied against the act.
In a letter sent to the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Justice Department in February, RILA and the Chamber were among the groups expressing concerns about portions of the law, including inadequate definitions of foreign official.
They added that confusion about when the law applies has had a chilling effect on legitimate business activity.
Now, representatives are particularly concerned about whether Wal-Mart was involved in lobbying against the law at the same time top executives were aware of possibly having violated it.
Wal-Mart allegedly spent more than $24 million bribing Mexico officials to get construction permits to help expand its reach in what's now its largest foreign subsidiary, the New York Times reported on Sunday.
The case also involve multiple instances in which Walmart de Mexico executives allegedly concealed the bribes from the company's U.S. headquarters.
Once the bribes were brought to the attention of U.S. executives, a preliminary investigation that confirmed possible illegal activity was shut down, against the recommendation of Wal-Mart's lead investigator, a former FBI agent, the Times said.
The committee now overseeing Wal-Mart's own investigation into the allegations is comprised entirely of independent directors.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Wal-Mart denied Wednesday that it pushed for changes to a federal anti-bribery law that it may have violated during an alleged bribery scheme in Mexico.
Wal-Mart has never lobbied on the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Simply because Wal-Mart is a member of an organization does not mean we agree with every position they take.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA) received letters Wednesday from Reps. asking for information and documents related to Wal-Mart's efforts to lobby for changes to the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
Top Wal-Mart executives serve on the boards of both organizations, which have lobbied against the act.
In a letter sent to the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Justice Department in February, RILA and the Chamber were among the groups expressing concerns about portions of the law, including inadequate definitions of foreign official.
They added that confusion about when the law applies has had a chilling effect on legitimate business activity.
Now, representatives are particularly concerned about whether Wal-Mart was involved in lobbying against the law at the same time top executives were aware of possibly having violated it.
Wal-Mart allegedly spent more than $24 million bribing Mexico officials to get construction permits to help expand its reach in what's now its largest foreign subsidiary, the New York Times reported on Sunday.
The case also involve multiple instances in which Walmart de Mexico executives allegedly concealed the bribes from the company's U.S. headquarters.
Once the bribes were brought to the attention of U.S. executives, a preliminary investigation that confirmed possible illegal activity was shut down, against the recommendation of Wal-Mart's lead investigator, a former FBI agent, the Times said.
The committee now overseeing Wal-Mart's own investigation into the allegations is comprised entirely of independent directors.
For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.
Labels:
anti-bribery law,
Bribery,
Corruption,
Fraud,
Mexico,
Wal Mart,
Walmex
Friday, July 2, 2010
Medical Marijuana Suit could be Trial Case
The Detroit Free Press
A Battle Creek man who legally uses marijuana for medicinal purposes is suing Wal-Mart for firing him after he tested positive for marijuana during a drug test.
The lawsuit was filed Tuesday in Calhoun County Circuit Court by the American Civil Liberties Union, its Michigan affiliate and the law firm of Daniel Grow, based in St. Joseph, on behalf of Joseph Casias, 30, who has an inoperable brain tumor and is in remission for sinus cancer. He said he uses marijuana at night to alleviate pain.
"It's very unfair that I was fired," Casias said. "I hope that this doesn't happen to other medical marijuana patients across the state."
As of Friday, the Michigan Department of Community Health has approved issuing medical marijuana cards to 20,548 patients and 8,905 caregivers, said Melanie Brim, director of the bureau of health professions within the department.
In 2008, Michigan voters approved medical marijuana use.
According to the suit, the Michigan Medical Marihuana Act "protects employees from being disciplined for their use of medical marihuana" in accordance with the law.
The law also says nothing in the act shall be construed to require "an employer to accommodate the ingestion of marihuana in any workplace or any employee working while under the influence of marihuana."
The lawsuit says Casias never ingested marijuana at work and never worked while under the influence.
Brim and Dan Korobkin, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Michigan, said that, to their knowledge, this is the first lawsuit of its kind in Michigan.
"This is a path-breaking case to protect all of the patients in Michigan, whose rights are now protected by Michigan law," Korobkin said.
In November 2009, Casias -- who was issued a registry card from the state in 2009 -- twisted his knee at work. According to the suit, the next day he had trouble walking, was treated and given a drug test.
Though Casias showed a store manager his card, he was ultimately fired for testing positive for the drug, the lawsuit says.
A Wal-Mart statement said the situation was "unfortunate."
"The issue is about the ability of our associates to do their jobs safely," the statement said. "As more states allow this treatment, employers are left without any guidelines except the federal standard."
Marijuana possession is still illegal under federal law.
The lawsuit was filed Tuesday in Calhoun County Circuit Court by the American Civil Liberties Union, its Michigan affiliate and the law firm of Daniel Grow, based in St. Joseph, on behalf of Joseph Casias, 30, who has an inoperable brain tumor and is in remission for sinus cancer. He said he uses marijuana at night to alleviate pain.
"It's very unfair that I was fired," Casias said. "I hope that this doesn't happen to other medical marijuana patients across the state."
As of Friday, the Michigan Department of Community Health has approved issuing medical marijuana cards to 20,548 patients and 8,905 caregivers, said Melanie Brim, director of the bureau of health professions within the department.
In 2008, Michigan voters approved medical marijuana use.
According to the suit, the Michigan Medical Marihuana Act "protects employees from being disciplined for their use of medical marihuana" in accordance with the law.
The law also says nothing in the act shall be construed to require "an employer to accommodate the ingestion of marihuana in any workplace or any employee working while under the influence of marihuana."
The lawsuit says Casias never ingested marijuana at work and never worked while under the influence.
Brim and Dan Korobkin, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Michigan, said that, to their knowledge, this is the first lawsuit of its kind in Michigan.
"This is a path-breaking case to protect all of the patients in Michigan, whose rights are now protected by Michigan law," Korobkin said.
In November 2009, Casias -- who was issued a registry card from the state in 2009 -- twisted his knee at work. According to the suit, the next day he had trouble walking, was treated and given a drug test.
Though Casias showed a store manager his card, he was ultimately fired for testing positive for the drug, the lawsuit says.
A Wal-Mart statement said the situation was "unfortunate."
"The issue is about the ability of our associates to do their jobs safely," the statement said. "As more states allow this treatment, employers are left without any guidelines except the federal standard."
Marijuana possession is still illegal under federal law.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Federal Court Ruling Moves Wal-Mart Class Action Forward
Arkansas News
A federal Court of Appeals certified what may be the largest potential class-action lawsuit in U.S. history.
In a 6-5 decision, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the lawsuit — Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores — could move forward, although the court did reduce the number of eligible plaintiffs from the original class size.
The gender discrimination claim alleges Wal-Mart failed to promote and pay women as equally as men. Some estimates have the per claim payout ranging between $500,000 and $1 million, meaning a possible monetary claim could reach the hundreds of billions of dollars.
This week’s court ruling was procedural and did not address the merits of the case.
In a 6-5 decision, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the lawsuit — Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores — could move forward, although the court did reduce the number of eligible plaintiffs from the original class size.
The gender discrimination claim alleges Wal-Mart failed to promote and pay women as equally as men. Some estimates have the per claim payout ranging between $500,000 and $1 million, meaning a possible monetary claim could reach the hundreds of billions of dollars.
This week’s court ruling was procedural and did not address the merits of the case.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Court Strikes Blow to Wal-Mart in Sex Bias Case
Reuters
A landmark sex-discrimination lawsuit against Wal-Mart Stores Inc may proceed as a class-action case, a federal appeals court said, dealing the retailer a major blow and exposing it to billions of dollars of potential damages.
More than 1 million women could be included in the class, after the 6-5 ruling by the Ninth Circuit court on Monday.
Wal-Mart said it would appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The original lawsuit, hailed by lawyers as the largest sex discrimination class-action in U.S. history when it was filed in 2001, claimed that Wal-Mart paid female workers less than male colleagues and gave them fewer promotions.
Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer and largest private U.S. employer, had asked the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco to undo class-action certification in the case that alleged discrimination in its more than 3,000 stores.
"It's a huge win for the plaintiffs, and a tremendous loss for Wal-Mart," said Paul Secunda, an associate professor of law at Marquette University Law School. Given the number of employees involved and many years of pay at issue, he said "the amount of liability can be many billions of dollars."
The lawsuit's reemergence follows years of work by Wal-Mart to improve its image, from efforts to become more eco-friendly to mobilizing resources for disaster relief.
Wal-Mart shares closed down 0.9 percent at $54.04 on the New York Stock Exchange. Analysts said the small decline may reflect that fact that investors know the case still faces years of litigation.
NOT TOO BIG
The class action will now cover claims made by women who have worked at Wal-Mart since June 2001.
"Although the size of this class action is large, mere size does not render a case unmanageable," Judge Michael Daly Hawkins wrote for the majority.
A lower court will decide whether the claims of those who worked between 1998 and 2001 can join the class.
Both sides squabbled over the new size of the class in light of the court's ruling.
Theodore Boutrous, who argued the case for Wal-Mart in front of the Ninth Circuit, said the ruling in effect whittled the size of the class down from roughly 1.6 million to 500,000. Seligman disagreed, saying claims from only about 20 percent of the class had been remanded to the lower court.
Boutrous said the ruling contradicted "numerous" decisions by other federal appeals courts, as well as the Supreme Court.
"We do not believe the claims alleged by the six individuals who brought this suit are representative of the experiences of our female associates," Wal-Mart General Counsel Jeff Gearhart said in a statement.
The Ninth Circuit court also ordered the lower court to consider whether to certify the class for claims of punitive damages.
The six judges in the majority were appointed to the court by Democratic presidents, while four of the five dissenting judges were appointed by Republican presidents.
"No court has ever certified a class like this one, until now. And with good reason," Judge Sandra Ikuta wrote in the lead dissent. Absent evidence of companywide discrimination, she said "there is nothing to bind these purported 1.5 million claims together in a single action."
Also dissenting was Chief Judge Alex Kozinski, a leading conservative whose view could carry weight if Wal-Mart appeals. He wrote that the plaintiffs who make up the approved class "have little in common but their sex and this lawsuit."
NOT UNMANAGEABLE
Class-action lawsuits generally make it easier for groups of plaintiffs to sue well-heeled corporations and have led to large payouts by tobacco makers, and oil and food companies.
The suit originated with Wal-Mart worker Betty Dukes who sued for sexual discrimination in 2001 with six other plaintiffs. A trial judge certified the case as a class-action in 2004.
According to plaintiffs, female workers were routinely steered away from management positions and into such jobs as cashiers, with little chance for promotion. Court documents cite one woman who was told she was not qualified to manage because she could not stack 50-pound bags of dog food.
Charles Sullivan, a professor at Seton Hall University School of Law, who specializes in employment law, said Wal-Mart would face "huge economic pressure" to settle the case if the Ninth Circuit ruling was allowed to stand.
"Even if there is only a small chance it could lose at trial, the risk of having tens of billions of dollars of potential liability is too great," said Sullivan.
But he noted that the Supreme Court has been unsympathetic to large class-actions of late.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


