Showing posts with label family law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label family law. Show all posts

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Divorce is on the rise, and it’s the baby boomers’ fault

Orignal Story: TheSpec.com

WASHINGTON — The wisdom about divorce in America goes something like this: the sexual revolution sparked a sharp rise in the divorce rate from 1950 until about 1980, leading to the famous formulation that half of all American marriages would end in an uncoupling, conscious or otherwise. But in the 1980s, the divorce rate began to decline. Economists Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolfers summed it up thusly in 2011: "Couples marrying after the 1970s were better calibrated about how their family life would play out and were likely better matched for a life together based upon modern gender roles. As such, they were likely in a better position to have their marriages survive than were those marrying in the 1970s." In Michigan a Novi Divorce Lawyer is closely following this trend.

But a new paper out this month from demographers at the University of Minnesota challenges the traditional narrative. Sheela Kennedy and Stephen Ruggles have found that the divorce rate hasn't declined since 1980, it has only flattened. And when they controlled for changes in the age composition of the married population (the U.S. population was younger in 1980, and younger couples have a higher risk for divorce), they found that the age-standardized divorce rate has actually risen by an astonishing 40 percent since then. A Newark Family Lawyer is not surprised by these statistics.

To make a long methodology short, the United States has done an uneven and often inadequate job collecting divorce data over the decades. The Census Bureau, noting this "long-standing void in data on marriages and divorces," added a battery of marriage and divorce-related questions to the American Community Survey in 2008. This paper is part of a first wave of research capitalizing on the new data and the new methods of analysis it allows.  An Oklahoma City Family Lawyer questions the accuracy of the data pulled.

A key point is that the rise of divorce has not occurred evenly across all age groups. A chart, "As they age, Boomers continue to get divorced," included in the study looked at what the authors call the prevalence of marital instability, which they define as "the percentage of ever-married persons who have ever been divorced or separated." The line for 1970 is comparatively flat—there wasn't much of a difference in the prevalence of divorce between young people and older people. But starting with the 1980 line you can see a bulge forming at the younger end of the age spectrum as the baby boomers started divorcing. Looking at the lines for 1995 and 2010, you can watch this bulge shift rightward as the boomers age: "The same people who had unprecedented divorce incidence in 1980 and 1990 when they were in their 20s and 30s are now in their 40s, 50s, and 60s. The Baby Boom generation was responsible for the extraordinary rise in marital instability after 1970. They are now middle-aged, but their pattern of high marital instability continues."  A Canadian County Family Lawyer has been observing these same trends.

The flipside of this finding is the relative rarity of divorce among younger Americans today. This is likely due to a variety of reasons: people are waiting longer to get married, and cohabitation is on the rise. In the 1970s, a couple might get married at 25 and be divorced by 30. But today, that same couple would be more likely to simply live together for a few years and then head their separate ways when things go south.  A Dearborn Family Lawyer is also monitoring this trend.

As an assessment of the health of American marriages, these findings cut two ways. On one hand, a divorce is a far more disruptive and messy life event than simply moving out of your partner's apartment. In that sense you have to applaud the wisdom of today's twenty- and thirty-somethings for taking their time before tying the knot. But as Reihan Salam notes at the National Review, cohabitating relationships sometimes produce children. And whether they happen via cohabitation or divorce, split-ups are bad for kids, studies have shown.  A Calhoun County Divorce Lawyer agrees that divorce is hard on everyone.

Monday, May 14, 2012

New York Revises Divorce Law Statutes

Story first appeared in The Wall Street Journal.

A state commission tasked with reviewing a contentious aspect of New York's divorce reform laws is four months behind in delivering an expected report, raising concerns that lawmakers will have little time to address recommendations before their session ends in June.

The independent Law Revision Commission now expects to submit its report May 31. Though the commission's suggestions aren't binding, several legislators have said they are waiting for the report before proposing amendments.

The law was one of a package of 2010 reforms that made New York the last state in the country to adopt no-fault divorce. It set a strict formula for awarding temporary alimony, the money one spouse gives the other during the divorce process.

Since its passage, the statute has come under criticism from many lawyers in the state, who say that the formula may work well for lower-income spouses with few assets but frequently produces lopsided awards for wealthier couples with more complex financial situations.

No independent data on the law have been made public. But a Binghamton Family Lawyer has pointed to numerous cases in which richer spouses, especially men, have been left nearly impoverished by the temporary awards.

Family lawyers, couples and others hoping the Legislature would address the issue before leaving Albany for the year said the opportunity was shrinking.

There are mancy concerns, and the statute has created a lot of issues. However, those involved cannot blame the commission—which has a limited budget and only five members—for the delay. They were given a lot of work to do in likely what was too short of a time period.

The Commission Chairman said that a rough consensus had emerged over months of meetings and outreach, although some numbers were still being analyzed.

For lower-income New Yorkers, the formula is working rather well. But for higher-income couples, rather than promoting settlements, it tends to promote litigation and frustrate settlements. The law currently applies to couples making up to $524,000 a year.

He said it was likely that the commission would recommend a lower-income cutoff where the formulaic approach no longer applies and maybe judicial discretion takes hold. The current income cap for the state's child-support formula of $136,00 was suggested, and $200,000 as possible thresholds.

Interviews with family lawyers across the state revealed continuing disagreement over whether such an adjustment would solve the problem. Some of the state's most influential legal groups also differ over another concern: whether the formula should apply to temporary alimony, be extended to final alimony or be eliminated.

The New York chapter of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers opposes a formula for final alimony at any income level.

Ages of spouses—as well as their education levels, assets and earning capacities—may all vary widely, something that a blind application of a formula can't address.

Even those who support the use of a formula in some instances questioned whether the current iteration was fair. As it stands, many feel that the formula does not result in a fair and equitable resolution.

The Women's Bar Association of the State of New York would support a modified formula for final alimony awards, applying only to couples earning up to $136,000 a year.

The co-supervisor of the Legal Aid Society's family law and domestic violence practice, and one of the original drafters of the legislation, said she hoped the changes to the law would be minimal. But she was most concerned that the formula be extended to cover final alimony awards. She feels that installing a formula for temporary maintenance awards has already made a huge difference for clients.

The report would "probably" address the question of whether the formula should be extended to final alimony, and another proposal that would make the duration of alimony proportional to the length of the marriage. But he declined to say what the recommendations would be.

He also declined to comment on whether the report would recommend that the law address how judges should allocate responsibility for mortgage payments or handle the distribution of income streams other than salary, such as one-time bonuses.


For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.
For national and worldwide related business news, visit the Peak News Room blog.
For local and Michigan business related news, visit the Michigan Business News blog.
For healthcare and medical related news, visit the Healthcare and Medical blog.
For real estate and home related news, visit the  Commercial and Residential Real Estate blog.
For technology and electronics related news, visit the Electronics America blog.
For organic SEO and web optimization related news, visit the SEO Done Right blog.

Friday, April 13, 2012

US Marriage Law Under Fire for Discrimination

Story first appeared in the Wall Street Journal.

The U.S. law that defines marriage as between a man and a woman went before a federal appeals court for the first time Wednesday, setting the stage for a battle over the constitutional rights of same-sex couples that could end at the Supreme Court.

The First Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston heard arguments from Boston Family Lawyers representing legally married gay couples and the state of Massachusetts, who claim that the Defense of Marriage Act violates equal-protection guarantees and interferes with the rights of states to make their own laws.

The 1996 law, widely known as DOMA, was defended in court by the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group, set up last year by the House of Representatives after the current Presidential administration said it wouldn't support the law.

The three judges on the appellate panel alluded Wednesday to standards used by the Supreme Court to consider whether Congress had a legitimate reason to pass DOMA. Among those: whether a "rational basis" existed for the law.

The former U.S. Solicitor who was hired to defend the law by the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group, argued that Congress had a "rational basis" to seek a uniform definition of marriage at a time when it appeared Hawaii would legalize gay marriage, which some feared would create a legal patchwork of definitions of marriage.

Congress has the power to define the terms it uses to distribute federal benefits. This is not in any way an effort to override the states' own definition" of marriage.

The civil rights project director of Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders, argued on behalf of the married same-sex couples that the law deserved "heightened scrutiny" from the court because it affected a group that faces discrimination in society. But even without that, DOMA failed to pass the lower, "rational basis" standard, because it was enacted largely for discriminatory purposes.

There's no problem that's being solved by DOMA.  The law was simply Congress's way of expressing its disapproval of same-sex couples marrying.

The President said this week that courts should show deference to Congress. He later made it clear that he was mainly talking about a series of cases from the 1930s onward in which courts have given Congress wide leeway to regulate interstate commerce. In general, the current Presidential administration and earlier administrations make it a policy to defend acts of Congress in court, but the Attorney General said the DOMA case was a rare exception in which the administration didn't believe it could find a good basis to defend the law.

DOMA prevents the federal government from recognizing marriages from the six states and District of Columbia that perform same-sex unions, denying those married couples access to joint income-tax filings, Social Security benefits and access to family health insurance, among other benefits.

Wednesday's hearing combined two lawsuits, one by married same-sex couples and widows seeking federal benefits and another by the state of Massachusetts claiming Congress overstepped its authority in passing DOMA because recognizing marriage is a state concern.

In 2010, a U.S. District Judge agreed with both those arguments, striking down a provision of the law, known as Section 3, that defines marriage as the union of a man and a woman for the purposes of federal law.  He didn't strike down the law's other provision, which says states aren't compelled to recognize same-sex unions performed elsewhere.

DOMA is under legal attack on multiple fronts. On Monday, five legally married New York same-sex couples sue in federal court, claiming DOMA had an unfair impact on couples in which one spouse is an immigrant who wants to gain legal residence.

In February, a district court judge in San Francisco found DOMA unconstitutional because it denied health benefits to the spouse of a federal employee in California who married her same-sex spouse in 2008.

Court watchers said none of the judges are known for strong stances on these issues, and there is no timetable for when they will issue a ruling.

If the First Circuit strikes down DOMA, it makes it more likely that the Supreme Court at some point will want to review all of this.  The Supreme Court has not shown an interest in according special status to gays and lesbians, even when they struck down an anti-sodomy law. But even if they didn't do that in this case, they could still strike down DOMA using the lesser, rational basis test.

For more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Same Sex Divorce Difficulties


Story first appeared in The Washington Post.

When the plaintiff showed up in court Friday to pursue a divorce, she first stopped to consult with her lawyer. Then she crossed the room to hug her ex, chatting happily until it was time to be seated.
They both want to get divorced. But a Prince George’s County judge said they could not, reasoning that because same-sex marriage is not legal in the state, neither is same-sex divorce.

Now the highest court in Maryland will decide whether he was right, and whether the women will be required to maintain a bond they’ve tried for almost two years to sever.

The case represents just one of the many blind spots in the legal infrastructure of same-sex marriage in America. Couples often have different rights when they cross jurisdictional lines and may not have the same status in the eyes of the federal government as they do in their home states. Family law is constantly evolving and election-year politics promise to heighten the already divisive passion surrounding the issue.

The plaintiff was 21 when she met the defendant at a meeting for gay and lesbian students and their allies at Montgomery College in Rockville. The two quickly fell in love and after a year decided to move in together. An engagement followed and when California legalized same-sex marriage in 2008, they flew to San Francisco, exchanged vows at the courthouse and spent the rest of the trip sight-seeing.

But soon after their return it became apparent that the marriage wasn’t working. They realized that the futures that they had in mind were very different and that they wanted different things.

The plaintiff moved to Hyattsville and purchased a home. The defendant remained in the District, where they had been living. The plaintiff knew that in order to file for a divorce in Maryland, spouses must first live apart for a year. In the summer of 2010, the plaintiff and the defendant, who have many mutual friends and an amicable relationship, spoke again and decided together that divorce was the best option for them.

They sought guidance at a free law clinic and were assured that the divorce was no problem — other same-sex couples had been granted divorces in the past. The plaintiff filed the requisite paperwork with Prince George’s County and on the day of the hearing, she and the defendant sat next to each other in court, playing Hangman and Tic-tac-toe to pass the time. They watched as one couple after another was granted a divorce.

The women had already divided their property. The divorce was uncontested and they had no outstanding issues for the court to resolve. They were sure their case was cut and dried. But when they were called to the bench — the last case of the day — the Judge said his decision would be delivered by mail.

Two weeks later the plaintiff received a letter saying that because she and the defendant are both women their divorce could not be granted.

The plaintiff recalls  how surprised and panicked she was about the idea of being legally tied to this person for the rest of her life.  The plaintiff is an effervescent, chatty woman who favors floral skirts and wears artsy glasses. On her left hand is a diamond ring. About two years ago, she met another woman.
After the divorce was denied, the plaintiff reached out to Lambda Legal, which put her in touch with her lawyer, who has seen many similar cases in her 30 years as a lawyer.  She says that about fifty percent of gay couples break up — just like straight people.

The plaintiff’s lawyer had one client move to D.C. from North Carolina solely for the purpose of pursuing a divorce after same-sex marriage became legal in the District. She has advised clients who live in Virginia and cannot divorce their same-sex spouses to get separation agreements that allow them some legal and financial protection. The plaintiff’s lawyer has worked with more than one person who has gotten hung up trying to adopt a child with a current partner while still legally married and unable to divorce a former spouse.

The plaintiff says moving on from the relationship is difficult when legal entanglements remain. The plaintiff is concerned about the type of entitlement her ex has on her house and car. Life would become even more complicated if either of the women had a baby or became ill and needed someone to make medical decisions on her behalf.  At that point, it would become far more than a typical family law case.

In March, the Governor signed legislation to legalize same-sex marriage in Maryland. But the law isn’t scheduled to go into effect until Jan. 1, 2013. If it goes through, the women would be able to divorce without a problem. But there is a referendum on the ballot to repeal the law — and the women and their lawyers aren’t willing to take the chance to see how it turns out.

On Friday, the legal director of the National Center for Lesbian Rights, argued the plaintiff’s case before a panel of eight judges at the Court of Appeals in Annapolis. The defendant and the plaintiff sat a row apart and eagerly looked on as it was explained that for more than 100 years Maryland courts have applied a “common law doctrine of comity” to recognize marriages that were valid in other states, even if they were illegal in Maryland, as was the case in a marriage between an uncle and niece.

There is no way of knowing when the judges will make a decision, but the plaintiff’s lawyer expects it will be a matter of months. If the divorce is not granted, the plaintiff and the defendant will have other options. Because same-sex marriage is now legal in the District, the defendant can file for divorce there.

But the plaintiff says the case — which has grown much more significant than she ever imagined — is not just about the two of them anymore. There is a similar case pending in Baltimore.  And the family lawyer has several other same-sex clients getting ready to file for divorces in Maryland.

Thursday, April 5, 2012

Smartphones In the Courtroom During Divorces

Story first appeared in Detroit Free Press.

If the smartphone in your pocket or purse seems critical to your daily life, imagine how important it could be to your spouse's divorce lawyer states a Raleigh Divorce Lawyer.

The modern cell phone brims with information divorce lawyers and judges are eager to see, such as text messages, photographs, videos, e-mail, Internet browser links, call histories, calendar entries and GPS tracking data.

Add that to the golden triumvirate through which private misbehavior now becomes permanently public -- Facebook, Twitter and YouTube postings -- and lawyers practicing family law have more electronic means than ever to settle those timeless "he said, she said" arguments with devastating certainty.

Consider the possibilities:

• Not bad-mouthing me to the kids? Really? Take a look at this text message you sent them.

• Can't find a job? Then why do you spend all day noodling websites that have nothing to do with work?

• In Omaha on business? So how did your iPhone "check in" on Facebook at this fancy restaurant in Boston? And who's with you in that picture?

In a recent survey of more than 800 divorce lawyers by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, 92% said they've seen more cases during the last three years using evidence taken from iPhones, Droids and other smartphones.

Ferreting out the details of an illicit relationship isn't really the purpose of collecting electronic evidence, lawyers said. Rather, it's all about the custody of two things that often are at the heart of family disputes: children and money.

A lawyer with a matrimonial practice in Kansas City, Mo., once represented a man who was fighting a demand from his ex-wife for additional maintenance payments. Her Facebook postings revealed that she had been spending lavishly on a maintenance issue of her own: cosmetic surgery.

The president of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, said electronic evidence is particularly good at giving clues to whether one party in a divorce case is selling assets or trying to hide assets. He once found a cryptic text message that led to evidence that his client's former spouse was hiding assets.

A St. Louis Family Lawyer said that on custody issues, judges are particularly sensitive to what parents say about each other to their children. Texts often illuminate that subject.

And credibility always is a key for judges. One of the clients found a photo on her husband's cell phone of him drying a load of marijuana. She forwarded it to her own phone while he was in another room.

When the husband denied having issues with drugs, the court was treated to 30 seconds of stunned silence as he looked at the picture.

But sometimes electronic evidence makes resolving a custody or paternity issue almost too easy. A Kansas City lawyer once uncovered a YouTube video that a man, who was claiming paternity of a child, had posted a couple of years before.  During an appearance on a reality TV show, the man adamantly insisted the child wasn't his.  That video, and not the man's testimony, decided the issue.

Parties in a lawsuit generally are entitled to electronic evidence, and laying hands on it has become fairly routine, lawyers said. Estranged spouses usually can count on text messages they've sent to each other to emerge if they're material to the case.

Children and spouses' friends also are steady sources of electronic communications. And information from shared computers and telephone accounts also is fair game, lawyers said.

Lawyers can request that people not destroy electronic evidence before the lawyers look at it.

The impulsive nature of electronic communications -- often visceral and sharp -- can make it powerful evidence in a divorce case already infused with raw emotions, lawyers said. In the light of calm reflection, even an idle threat looks far worse on a page with an evidence sticker attached.

So how to avoid that moment? Lawyers advise never to write or text anything that you wouldn't want a judge to read.

To read more law related news, visit the Nation of Law blog.